Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 26 · 1 July 1898
4printed page
scan 4 of 16

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 26.

(continued from page 3)

…and the wars of the La Plata states too have already been over for some time. But who knows the treacheries of a volcano?

In this land Baron Hirsch resolved to settle a great number of homeless Jews. The plans ran at first into the monstrous. A very modest realisation has followed. Some 7000 souls were counted a short while ago in the Jewish colonies of Argentina. Even this figure is probably now set too high, since the colonists are fleeing from the colonies by hundreds. Only a few weeks ago there went through the press of Europe and of America tidings which, like a flash of lightning in a dark and stormy night, threw a glaring, if only brief, gleam upon the darkness that the Jewish Colonisation Association has known how cleverly to spread over these colonies. It will perhaps be said that this society brought out only recently a report upon the flourishing of the Argentine colonies, and that one cannot therefore well speak of a darkness. We will reproduce this report briefly and compare it with the reports of the Argentine journals and with the original reports which are at our disposal.

For this a few words upon the conditions of Argentina in general are needful. Argentina may with pride call her own not only the highest mountain of America, but also perhaps the greatest national debt in the world, if one compares the height of the burden of debt with the number of inhabitants.

When the former President of Argentina, Pelegrini, laid before the National Congress the causes of the Argentine state bankruptcy of the year 1890, when he uncovered the mania for speculation of the governments and of highly placed personages, and condemned in the harshest expressions the crass proceedings in the National Bank and in the provincial banks, the dishonesty and disorder which prevailed among high and low, he too brought forward quite particularly the sorry conduct of the officials. They drew twenty to thirty times their salary. In spite of this they were open to bribery everywhere and towards everyone. Corruption had seized the whole army of officials, which was at least twice as large as it needed to be. The State and its inhabitants worked for the officials, who did or left undone what they pleased.

As is known, the Argentine Government made the greatest exertions to set its shattered finances on their feet again. To the European immigrants in particular great favours were promised, as for example free passage, large concessions upon the purchase of land or upon settlement in the towns, &c. This too had its effect. Immigration increased rapidly. Italians, Frenchmen, Basques, Englishmen in particular, but also inhabitants of other American states, sought out the hospitable land. Then Baron Hirsch, or rather his advisers, found it likewise time to carry out their plans. In the year 1889 the colony of Moisesville was founded.

We will not follow the founding of the remaining colonies in detail. It is enough to know that the Jewish Colonisation Association became the body which after the death of Baron Hirsch directed the Argentine colonisation. It always gave very reassuring reports upon the development of the colonies, and when here and there evil tidings came to light concerning the state of the colonies or the treatment of the colonists by the administration, they were usually contradicted with despatch. It was disquieting, however, that the Jewish press could not come to rest. While one part of it saw itself again and again compelled to publish unfavourable reports, the other part brought the most charming descriptions of the conditions in the colonies entrusted to the keeping of the J. C. A. These fair descriptions have now ceased. The evil tidings, on the other hand, remained uncontradicted. And they were bound to remain so; for the colonists who have but lately returned to Europe and North America could report what they had themselves lived through and could bring forward classical witnesses.

What said the J. C. A. to this? From its official annual report upon the year 1897 we take the following statements:

"Assuredly not all the difficulties are yet removed. We cannot say that the population which was transplanted to Argentina has already now acquired all the qualities of old agricultural peoples. Their education is not yet at an end. We are happy, however, to be able to state that a great advance has been achieved. The last harvest was satisfactory...

The colonists appear now to have taken root in the soil upon which they labour. We are no longer approached with petitions to be conveyed back to the former home... There are even colonists who at their own cost have their parents come from Russia. When these arrive in Argentina they do not find themselves left solitary, they are supported by their kinsfolk, and this colonisation we encourage.

The Argentine Government has itself acknowledged the services which the colonists have rendered in the provinces in which they are settled. The official reports of the inspectors state that the colonists have given value to a considerable area of uncultivated land and that their activity has procured an undeniable prosperity for regions hitherto waste."

That is all that the "J. C. A." knows how to say in general upon the colonisation in Argentina. Then follows a summary statement of the number of the population of the colonies, of the areas under cultivation (in hectares), the enumeration of the schools, and the report upon the state of health of the colonists. The latter is described as good; only there were "a fairly large number of cases of typhoid fever," against which measures had been taken. Physicians are still lacking in the several colonies. Then a small paragraph discusses the self-government of the colonists. In the colonies of Entre Rios the system has not yet been introduced, because the colonies are said to be too young. In Mauricio and Moisesville self-government exists. The commission of the colonists of Mauricio numbers five members, which has to occupy itself with the communal affairs and with the care of hospital and slaughter-house. It has also to negotiate with the contractors for the threshing and to supervise the Hebrew instruction.

In Moisesville the colonists have to furnish two representatives to the administration. For the rest, the colonists are also said to form a committee of public works, which is recognised by the provincial government. This so-called system of self-administration is, as the report upon Argentina concludes, to "give the colonists the consciousness of their freedom and of their responsibility!"

When one reads this report, there must certainly strike everyone — apart from the unintended but for that reason all the bitterer scorn of the last words — this one thing, that the report indulges itself in a few sentences which say nothing of importance, and that it employs turns of phrase apt to throw a singular light upon the conduct of the "J. C. A." We will furnish no commentaries. We have only underlined a few passages. The frightful banality of the passage which speaks of the judgment of the inspectors we must, however, particularly emphasise. Never yet has an official report said so utterly nothing and so much as that which the "J. C. A." is not ashamed to publish. The report states that land formerly uncultivated