Die Welt · Vol. II, No. 20 · 20 May 1898
5printed page
scan 5 of 16
Facsimile · scan 5 of 16
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

(continued from page 4)

…movement of civilised humanity will at once perceive. And conversely this Jewish commonwealth in Palestine will raise every Jew in the world in his standing and his worth in the midst of his fellow-countrymen. You are rightly proud of the Englishman Disraeli, the Italians Luzatti and Ottolenghi, the Frenchman Cremieux. You throw out your chest when these generals, these ministers are named. Well then: the means of having many Cremieux, many Ottolenghis and Luzzatis, many Disraelis, is the creation of a Jewish commonwealth. We Zionists have the confidence that the Jews returning to Palestine will do honour to the Jews who remain in their fatherland. As we all must feel shame to-day when the enslaved Jews of the East are cast up at us, so you will all be permitted to carry your heads higher when the new land of Zion shall have compelled the world to respect Jewish capability. Far from being a danger to Judaism, Zionism signifies the sole salvation for those Jews who without it would perish, and an elevation in rank for those Jews who believe they stand in no need of salvation. And whoever does not denounce Peter's Pence as a disavowal of the love of country will consistently be unable to charge the Jew with having no fatherland, if he, without himself giving up his home, helps the brethren who dream of a new existence to the realisation of their dream.

There remains the last objection: Zionism is an impracticable chimera. To this let only the briefest answer be given. So long as a plan stands merely upon paper, its opponents can always maintain that it is impracticable. With mere words one can never compel them to strike sail. The only means of proving to them categorically that they are in error is precisely the realisation of the plan. This proof we hope to be able to furnish. Upon what do we rest our hope? Upon the conviction that all the premises of the critics who call Zionism a chimera are false. "There is no Jewish people!" we were told. At Basle there were assembled 204 men from all parts of the world who avowed themselves with enthusiasm members, representatives, of a single people. "The Jews have no wish at all to return to Palestine!" These 204 Jews at Basle gave the assurance that behind them stand several hundred thousand Jews who are ready this very day, at the first sign, to gird their loins and journey towards Zion. "The Jews have become a nation of hucksters and will never again learn to guide the plough!" All the Jews who have been settled in the agricultural colonies of Palestine have proved themselves, under the most unfavourable conditions, incomparably tenacious, industrious and skilful tillers of the soil. "Palestine cannot possibly receive the Jews." Palestine — with the adjoining provinces — offers ample room for 12 to 15 millions of inhabitants who, beside agriculture, would also carry on industry and serve a transit traffic and a world commerce still to be developed. "Palestine is surely not uninhabited, and the population will not be willing to let itself be displaced!" We wish to displace nobody, and we have proofs already now that the six hundred thousand Arabs who dwell to-day in the Holy Land will keep good neighbourhood with the incoming Jews. "The question of language will form an insuperable obstacle." For people who, equipped with nothing but their jargon, come to London and in three months speak English tolerably, in two years like natives; who land in Argentina and after half a year chat fluently in Spanish with the gauchos, a difficulty of language simply does not exist. "The Powers will never consent that Palestine should become Jewish." Which Powers? Turkey? She is ready to receive the Jews if advantages are offered her in return. The other Powers? Those which are tormented by the Jewish question welcome every solution of the difficulty, and the Zionist most of all, because it is the most thorough. "Christendom will never leave to the Jews the guardianship of the holy places!" Neither do we ask that at all. For the present let everything remain as it is. So long as the Christian Powers do not deem us worthy of the honour of mounting guard at the Holy Sepulchre, let the Turkish sentry go on shouldering his rifle at the entrance of the Church of the Sepulchre. But Christendom will soon recognise that we have at least as much claim upon its confidence as Islam, and it will not withhold it from us. Those who hold the difficulties of Zionism to be insuperable suffer from a fear of ghosts. The matter is, though not exclusively, yet essentially, a question of money. You say: "Zionism is impracticable, therefore we hold ourselves aloof from it." I answer you: "You hold yourselves aloof from Zionism, therefore it is impracticable." If the well-to-do, the rich Jews were willing to come to the aid of the poor, who wish to become the first citizens of the Jewish commonwealth in Zion, with money — not with alms! only with a well-secured loan bearing decent interest — then Zion would in the shortest time be no poet's word, but a political reality. The opportunity of working with your money at the realisation of the Zionist thought will be offered you in the coming weeks, when the appeal goes forth to you to subscribe contributions for the Jewish Colonial Bank now in course of foundation.

And now I sum up my all too long argument quite briefly. Only those Jews are right in rejecting Zionism who desire the disappearance of Judaism. But these opponents may not decently have a voice in the matter, since Zionism is not their affair, but the affair of those Jews who wish for the preservation of Judaism. The preservation of Judaism is impossible if the present condition continues. The educated Jews will fall away, the uneducated will go to ruin, if no better moral and economic conditions of existence are created for them. Zionism is for many Jews salvation, for no Jew a danger. The impracticability of Zionism is a fable of the faint-hearted, who can form no notion of a house so long as it is not built quite finished, nay, even dried out by being lived in. And my last word is: Judaism will be Zionist, or it will not be at all!


The Second Basle Congress.

19th May 1898.

The cross-purposes intrigues which had already begun against the organisers of the Second Congress have now received vigorous answers. The editorial staff of the "Hamagid," for example, which granted admission to an article by Dr. Kaminka that agitated in a coarse fashion against the Congress and the Actions Committee, has in one week received over 300 declarations of protest against this article. Declarations have also been sent in to the Committee from many other quarters, condemning these machinations in the sharpest terms and expressing themselves with enthusiasm for the Second Congress and the Colonial Bank.

* * *

The Committee has called upon the holders of shekel-books to send in the blocks. It is urgently recommended that all preliminary work be hastened, so that difficulties may not arise at the last moment through the mass of the material. It is especially in the interest of those,