Page 14. — "Die Welt" — No. 19.
(continued from page 13)
…when the house has just been plundered, or when one has just been massacred. That is why I believe that it is among such people that you can most readily find adherents. I hold your movement on the whole to be better suited to the lower strata. People of our sort have no need of it.
For all that, I do acknowledge that the idea is a fine one. But, as I have said, I cannot bring myself to come forward so pronouncedly.
People take everything amiss if one is a Jew. Even the writing of books. The other day somebody in the Vienna Parliament took exception to it. The gentleman, moreover, does not appear to be exactly a friend of education in other respects either. For when the deputy Verkauf began to quote from political economy, he cried out: "Oh dear, a book! I don't like that!" But then he gave the ground of his aversion by asserting: "The books are only copied by one Jew from another in any case!" There one sees how injustice is done to the Jews. It really is not true that the Jews write all the books. Still, it is dangerous enough to make oneself conspicuous in this fashion. If Heine had written no books, he might perhaps have a monument to-day. One really does nothing but harm oneself, whatever one takes in hand.
There are moments when I am almost resolved to become one of yours. When I see in what manner the Jews are reviled, how great the hatred is, and how inhumanly everything about us is dragged in the mire - then I do believe in the necessity of setting up again the self-respect of a downtrodden and persecuted people. I mean the three thousand gallows for Jews that were demanded in the debate upon the corn duties. A spectacle it would be, no doubt; but since it is only Jews that are to be hanged, exploiters enough would still be left over, and bread would not grow cheaper. Have we really any need to be slaughtered as scapegoats in every distress and embarrassment? The majority of the Jews go hungry too, and the corn that passes through rich Jewish hands would perhaps just suffice to stop the poor Jewish mouths. There would still remain a great residue of such as hunger in other confessions.
That it is not always the Jews who understand the art of exploiting may be seen at present in Palestine. There the immigrant Germans are the holders of the wholesale trade. The Jews are the small dealers, and verily they sigh enough. As business is carried on in our social order to-day, there are simply no national grounds for exploitation.
Upon such occasions, as in this affair of the gallows, I always have the wish that the Jews would band together and put up with nothing. But then I think again of the unpleasantness and of the sensation; every man must nowadays look out for himself, must he not? And I still hope that with modesty and humility more peaceable conditions might be attained.
In America people do not appear to be so severe against the Jews as yet. There it has been permitted that a Jewish regiment of 5000 volunteers should be formed and offer itself for war service. I have not yet heard that anyone has discerned an importunity in this, or that American students have denied these Jewish soldiers beforehand the honour of bearing arms. In the end this regiment may even succeed in distinguishing itself in the field, without anti-Semitism in America growing greater on that account. Among us such a thing could not occur; it would at once be said that the battlefields had been Judaised.
For the rest, the poor Jews among us do not fare so well either as I had believed. That Jewish beggars are beggarly poor I knew well enough; but that they must now suffer doubly I learned only when an acquaintance told me that he had recognised a beggar for a Jew and shown him the door. My acquaintance had no notion that I am a Jew. Well, yes, one does not always possess the moral courage which the "son of the much-lauded, great, scripture-learned Rabbi Israel of Saragossa" showed towards the anti-Semitic alcalde's daughter. In short, I had not yet enlightened my acquaintance upon this dark point in my life, and when he told me this story I kept silence, because I wished to spare him an embarrassment. But afterwards I have had to think so much upon it — how the poor and the defenceless must endure the most of that hatred which we for the most part learn of from newspaper reports — and so I wrote to my friend that he had better not tell me such things in future, because — and I told him, straight out, who I am.
As I have said, I stand in sympathy with your movement, and you see, I am already beginning to give my sentiments effect.
Yours devotedly, An Undecided Man.
The World of Books.
History of Religion in Antiquity down to Alexander the Great. By C. P. Tiele. Authorised German edition by G. Gehrich. Vol. I. First half: History of the Egyptian and of the Babylonian-Assyrian Religion. Gotha, 1897. Octavo.
He who has never pursued comparative studies in the field of the history of religion is as little able to do justice to a scientific understanding of Judaism as the physician who does not know the anatomy and physiology of the vertebrates is in a position to comprehend and appreciate the human organism scientifically. It is therefore indispensably necessary that everyone who wishes to attain a scientific knowledge of Jewish faith and Jewish life should, besides his own, make himself more exactly acquainted with the more important historical religions in their development. Only through the study of foreign religions is the eye sharpened for the specific peculiarity and the eternal content of one's own; only thus does one learn, in this religion also, to separate objectively and reverently the imperishable truth from the perishable similitude.
The excellent book before us contains no general history of the religions of antiquity, but only the actual history of religion. This is not a description of all religions arranged according to some given principle, be it that of mutual affinity or that of the degree of development attained, but a portrayal of the development of religion, that is, of religious man, in the history of mankind. It does not proceed from a definite presupposition, but is founded upon the observation and investigation of what has actually happened; it is discerned solely from the history of religions that stand in historical connection with one another. Every historical religion contributes its own share, through its peculiar and one-sided development, to the general development of religion; and the religions of peoples that come into contact with one another act upon one another either fertilisingly or — even when they combat one another — formatively. S.
"On Jewish Colonists in Erez Israel," by S. Bromberg. Warsaw 5658. (Judaeo-German.)
The author of this little tract wishes to give a "correct explanation of Zionism." If he has not succeeded in this to the same degree as the Jargon works of Scholem-Alechem which we have already discussed, we nevertheless owe to the brochure the communication of a letter which Rabbi Elias of Gröditz addressed to Rabbi Chaim Elcasar of Kalisch, and which the latter has taken up into his work "חיי עולם." Rabbi Elias here adduces, with the great apparatus of his Talmudic learning, the proof that the redemption of Israel can come to pass only when it shall live and labour upon the soil of its fathers. This letter of an orthodox rabbi is one argument more for the untenableness of those scruples which in certain circles men profess to entertain against Zionism upon religious (?) grounds. M. B.
Our fellow-thinker Bernard Lazare has lately published a collection of sketches and symbolic tales, "La Porte d'ivoire" (The Ivory Gate), with Armand Colin & Cie. in Paris.
