Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 8.
(continued from page 5)
…Jewish journalists who work for Jewish papers are for the most part anti-Zionists and cry out in horror: "Mission," "Danger," "Assimilation," and so forth. The Englishman does indeed say: "Everyone has his opinion." But every opinion must be consistent — words and deeds must tally.
The most important principle of Zionism is that the Jews are a nation. Our opponents, however, maintain that we are merely a "religious community" — a "sect," Mr. Claude Montefiore would say. Yet the views of every people are laid down in its press — for good or ill, a newspaper remains a voice of the nation. "The Jews," say the leading articles of the Jewish papers, "are no nation." But every following page appeals to the national instincts of Israel. This I can confirm from long years of practice. In the seven years during which I have read weekly all the Jewish papers of England, America, Austria, Germany, Holland, France, Australia, and so forth, I have come to the conviction that the anti-national attitude of these papers does not accord with the contents of most of them.
Let us see. If the Jews were really a sect or religious group, the Jewish papers would have to occupy themselves with religious questions — the synagogue and the Kahal would be their sole domain. In England we have a few such religious Christian papers, and in America too we can find them. But in Jewish journalism I know of only one such paper: "The Reform Advocate" in Chicago, which serves the interests of the "Reform Jews." In this paper Dr. Schreiber lately wrote that a Jewish paper has nothing to do with the social and political affairs of the Jews of all countries. That, at least, is consistent. It reminds me of a theatre director in Paris who, when a bill for cat food was presented to him, remarked: "If there are no rats here, what are the cats for; and if there are rats again, what is the food for?" If there is no Jewish nation, why do the Jewish papers fill their columns with news of a national nature; and if, on the other hand, the nation does exist, why do they deny its existence? The whole significance of a paper lies, after all, in its satisfying a specific interest. Here, for example, I find the "Jewish Chronicle," which fills its forty pages with all manner of political and social information about the Jews from China to Peru, and not a single article among them deals with a religious question. And the orthodox "Mainzer Israelit," or the reform-hungry "Allgemeine Zeitung des Judenthums"! How comes it that these anti-national papers open their columns first and foremost to political or social information? With the papers written in Hebrew, Yiddish, or Polish it is similar. Whence comes this? Whence, if not from concern for the welfare of the nation, or, if you prefer, of the people?
A man whom I should like to call my guide in the profession once said to me: "There is a Jewish point of view in everything." That is not only true, but it is precisely this that makes the Jewish papers what they are — the most peculiar papers under the sun. If this is correct, then the attitude of the editors of Jewish papers is entirely wanting in logic and justification. Moreover, a religious paper would be but little read. If there is no nation, then there are no national affairs, and between the orthodox and reformed congregations there would be no connection at all. Such connections would, besides, be impractical, and if practical, then useless. Jewish congregations are, after all, for the most part led by men who satisfy religious needs according to financial possibilities.
And now, how does it nevertheless come about that those who combat its existence in the most vehement manner devote their attention to the ideas, feelings, and habits of the nation? We ask, and find no answer.
Hungarian Press Voices.
Of the clerical papers, which in Hungary too scatter nothing but hatred and calumny against the Jews, as well as of the malicious non-Magyar journals, there shall be no talk here. But it must appear striking, especially to the foreigner, that the organs of one wing of the extreme Left — that is, papers professing to be radically liberal — and of the National (Apponyi) Party incessantly cultivate, in word and picture, an anti-Semitism now half-concealed, now open. This is proved by the attitude of the daily papers "Ellenzék," "Magyarország," "Budapesti Hirlap," and of the illustrated weekly "Kakas Márton" towards the Paris sensational trial. There Zola and his adherents are belittled, reviled, and cast under suspicion, while Boisdeffre is celebrated as the herald of the purest truth and Esterhazy as spotless. Whoever has not read the "Budapesti Hirlap" of the 10th of February of this year would not believe that, while its special correspondent writes decidedly against Zola and gloatingly prophesies his conviction, in another part of the same paper and the same number a leading article makes the wavering attempt to be impartial and to glorify Zola. But because it does not come from the heart, the uncomfortable undertaking will not succeed with him, as the following passages testify: "Can that man be innocent in whose affair the two most eminent French military tribunals have judged alike? ..... And the manner in which Dreyfus's patrons have administered the question, with the help of monstrous sums of money, in France, but especially in the remaining parts of Europe, has fed this odious conception all too greatly. In all likelihood the Zola trial, too, will bring us no light into the mysteries."
After further rolling of the eyes, the distinguished leader-writer soars to the following cheap bravery: "If I were Dreyfus, I would perhaps rather bear innocently the fetters and the shame of the crime than, by the stirring-up of my affair, cast down the Republic and its leaders as victims of the above shameful machinations. As Casimir Périer, I too would have said before the jurors only this much: Out of constitutional regard I am unable to tell the truth in its full extent."
From such press voices and moods let the thinking Jew form for himself a picture of how, more or less, a — Hungarian Dreyfus would fare.
But a Jewish paper reproaches the "Welt" with fairly hunting out every opportunity to represent, with a certain complacency, the situation of the Jews as precarious in Hungary too.
That Hungarian-Jewish paper (which denounces even the tamest Zionists as traitors to the fatherland) pretends, with its ostrich tactics, to serve the fatherland. As though Hungary were boarded up and unnoticed by the great world. As though one did not serve the fatherland more honestly and more successfully by uncovering the abuses and seeking their improvement. On the other hand, it is surely the duty of a Jewish world-paper to sketch as complete a picture as possible of the situation of all Jews; for otherwise it might come to pass that, for example, Hungary would be cried up as a Jewish Eldorado and flooded by swarms of unhappy Jews from other countries, which in turn might become quite disagreeable to our assimilants and simulants.
Dr. J. Rónai.
Belgrade Letter.
Belgrade, in February.
The Jews of the small Oriental states have hankerings after assimilation. Young people, too, wish to nibble at the draught which their brethren of the race in the West of Europe have, since 1789, 1848, or since 1867, gulped down so greedily that it now causes them a desperate morning-after misery. The Spanish Jews in Bulgaria and Servia are no longer to be called Jews, for that word is proscribed, but at most "Servians of the Mosaic confession" and "Bulgarians of the Mosaic confession." Away with everything Jewish about them, away with the separatist manners and customs; into the lumber-chest with the Spanish language, with that "dialect of our grimmest enemies and persecutors." They are to feel and think as Servian-nationals, respectively Bulgarian-nationals, and in each and every thing to resemble their Christian brethren. Only the language of their country are they to learn, and this alone may henceforth be used at home and in the street, in the temple and at social gatherings. Societies and associations are being created, with statutes of draconian severity, whose sole purpose is to extirpate the Spanish idiom, root
