No. 2: — "Die Welt" — Page 3.
(continued from page 2)
…make precise inquiry, for once, whether in any army an officer would be tolerated who had similar "private affairs." But the Herr Major does declare that he "sincerely regrets" these things. More seems not at all to be desired of him.
* * *
The court-martial, which in these days behind closed doors cultivates comradely conviviality, knows quite well that the "Count" Walsin-Esterhazy is a desperado. The judges know the story of the Rothschild collection; they know that the esteemed accused works in dirty money-manoeuvres. They credit him, in his "private life," with every unworthiness, every perfidy. They know that this desperate existence could keep its head above water only by desperate means, — but that he forged the bordereau, that he plunged Captain Dreyfus into ruin, and hatched this whole wretched affair for the sake of an advantage, that they do not credit him with. In logical consideration of his disreputable past, they are convinced of his incapacity to commit a crime.
* * *
The defence counsel need only rise and say: Gentlemen! If you consider that Walsin-Esterhazy has never acted conscientiously, if you take into account that he has led the life of an adventurer, that he has always stood at the edge of the abyss, then you will come to the conclusion that for this gallant man there was no reason to commit a treason." The defence counsel could say much more, were he not in the agreeable position of being able to make himself comfortable. Well, the court-martial will arrive at this conclusion, and the "gallant man" will again go strolling in Paris before these lines even leave the press.
* * *
The court-martial is consistent. A man who has forfeited the right to be addressed as a gentleman is, before it, held to be exalted above every suspicion. Thus it is then only natural that Dreyfus, who in all his days committed nothing evil, who lived in comfortably ordered circumstances, Dreyfus, of whom it became known that the German government thrice refused him entry into Alsace, was urgently suspected of being a high traitor.
* * *
Public opinion in France is no less consistent than the court-martial. Esterhazy, the deep-dark man of honour, counts with it as a good soldier. The man who expressed the wish to enter Paris as a conqueror, as an excellent patriot. Then Zola must be a scoundrel, the worthy Scheurer-Kestner a traitor, the brave Colonel Picquard a slanderer, Bernhard Lazare, Mathieu Dreyfus, and the other unimpeachable people all blackguards. Only Esterhazy remains an honest man. "Tell me whom you suspect, and I will tell you who you are."
* * *
Again the doors to the court-martial have been closed, and again one has had to hear that the defence of the fatherland requires this secret-mongering, for the sake of the "honour of the army." One should beware of declaring that it were possible that the honour of the army could bear so little light. Let one take care, for one day people will after all begin to believe it.
* * *
For the present, to be sure, they still greet Esterhazy with cheers. The officers honour him by baring their heads. It has long been known that he must be acquitted; the army is once again saved, and with it the country. The slanderer Piquard will be indicted, and General Gonse, whose memory and conviction underwent a transformation so very much at the right moment, will continue to count as an ornament of the army. Paty du Clam too, the well-known impeccable examining magistrate in the Dreyfus affair, remains an officer of whom the army is proud. The bit of broken word and partiality that is publicly reproached to him he will outlast as triumphantly as Esterhazy his "private affairs." And the people will again cry: "Vive l'armée! Vive la France!"
* * *
On the boulevards, in the cafés, and in the foyers of the theatres, the merry folk buy the cheap little Jews of paper and, for their amusement, pluck at the topical little nose-string. Voila, l'affaire Dreyfus! A harmless pleasure, which harms no one but poor noses that cannot grow long enough. But the man who invented this jest has thereby also given an ingenious symbol for the situation of the Jews of today. And the president of the court-martial, who knew how so teasingly to pluck and tousle Herr Mathieu Dreyfus, has taught the Parisians how that game must be thoroughly carried on. What was it, then, that our anti-Semitic paper said of the paper Dreyfus affair? "It is being bought in masses!"
Zionism.*)
Under the semblance of benevolence toward those endeavours which would remedy the political and social distress of the Jews existing in various countries of Europe, through a rational colonization first of all of the proletarian Jewish masses, the Arabia-traveller Dr. Glaser has attempted, in this place ("B. T."), to deliver a blow against Zionism. The "Berliner Tageblatt" does not stand friendly toward our Zionist endeavours. Nevertheless I expect of your courtesy that you will grant space to the following explanations.
Dr. Glaser, who would likewise settle the proletarian Jewish masses, though not where they wish it, but where he wishes it, namely in Arabia, Dr. Glaser desired, in good logic, above all to undermine the Palestinian colonization, and he seems to believe that his isolated idea would then of itself force itself upon the representatives of Jewry. To this end he now tells the world his very Arabian tales. The Zionists are supposed to stand in the service of English policy; they are supposed to intend the "first real cutting-up and partition of the Turkish empire"; he already sees the "eventual Jewish land-army" — which, to be sure, "because of its small number will impress neither the French nor anyone else" — take the field, at the side of the English land-army, against the "Russians and French advancing by land from the north." If one asks Herr Dr. Glaser, he will perhaps at once also relate the course of the battle, in which the "eventual Jewish land-army" naturally gets the worst of it, because it did not, according to Glaser's counsel, take itself off sideways into the Arabian bushes. Does that still require a thorough refutation? These are stories over which one falls asleep standing up.
But we Jews have already had so much to endure from blood-tales and other fables that experience bids us strangle the harmful fables while they are still young and small. The truth is that the Zionists make just as little a "purely English" as an "anti-French, anti-Russian, or anti-Turkish" policy. The Zionists want quite simply that which they frankly formulated in the program-clause at the Basle Congress:
"The creation of a homestead, secured under public law, for those Jews who cannot or will not assimilate at their present places of residence."
*) Under this title Dr. Theodor Herzl wrote in the "Berliner Tageblatt" of 4 January of the current year the above reply to the article of the Arabia-traveller Dr. Eduard Glaser: "Zionism. A Renewed Unrolling of the Oriental Question." We reproduce this reply here in extenso.
The Editors.
