Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 27 · 3 December 1897
5printed page
scan 9 of 20
Facsimile · scan 9 of 20
Scan of p. 5
English · AI translation, checked against the German

No. 27. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

(continued from page 4)

...venture upon social problems without having studied the concrete social conditions that underlie them. And it is a lamentable thing how pitifully little all the Jewish religious community boards and corporations, with their millionaires and professors, have accomplished toward the understanding, let alone the improvement, of the intellectual and social condition of their own people. Can anyone give us an answer when we ask: "Into what occupations do the 120,000 Jews of Vienna fall? How many Jews immigrate into Vienna each year?" Or: "How many Jewish professional poor are there in Vienna? How many persons incapable of work, and how many widows with small children, does Vienna count who require not a passing relief but a permanent maintenance?" These questions no one will be able to answer — save those who are ever ready with their phrases, "a great many, a few, and the like." Yet with this superficiality, with this total ignorance of the actual conditions, men forge plans of reform whose profitableness they can guarantee at most out of their own vanity.

Therein lies the trouble. No one seeks out poverty at its source, no one has inquired into its causes. People wait until the poor man knocks at the door and then humiliate him through their "help." The religious community board of the city of Vienna, with over 120,000 Jews, spends 800 Gulden a month on the relief of the poor. The board's poor-relief department shows 5,000 pauper's tickets already relieved once or repeatedly. Among them are about 3,000 widows who, robbed of their breadwinner, must be maintained permanently. But how many are there who would rather hunger and suffer want than stretch out their hand; how many who ask only for work and not for alms?

And the reform is indeed meant for them too, not merely for the professional beggars or those incapable of work. For that reason one must know how they all suffer, in order to find the means by which each may be helped according to his circumstances.

One thing is thus certain: the material on the condition of the poor Jewish population of Vienna must be compiled before any reform of poor-relief is undertaken at all. The only way to this is the enquiry.

This the religious community board has already convened for the 8th of December. But what irony! The historical concept of the enquiry has received a new interpretation in the Seitenstettengasse. Science sees the purpose of an enquiry*) either in the rendering of expert opinions and counsels on the basis of an available body of overall findings, or in the communication of an actual body of ideas or of sentiment. In the first case the enquiry is called incomplete, in the latter complete. The most magnificent proof of the soundness of this procedure in social reforms we find in the English Blue Books. Recently, too, complete enquiries into women's labour, apprenticeship, and the like have been held in Vienna. The gentlemen of the Seitenstettengasse, however, have devised for themselves an entirely new conception of the enquiry. They lay before us no summary result of investigations into the condition of the poor Jewish population, for they have made no investigations; nor do they ask any body of opinion from the experts whom they invite; rather they draw up a questionnaire and demand expert opinions whose grounds each individual will have to seek in his imagination, or at most in his personal experience, scarcely extending beyond a few cases. It is asked whether paid religious-community officials or voluntary poor-relief workers are the better recommended for poor-relief, what conditions ought to be decisive for the granting of poor-relief, whether there should be a cooperation between the religious community board and the private charitable institutions, and so forth.

*) Das Verfahren bei Enqueten über sociale Verhältnisse, by Embden, Cohn, and Streda, Leipzig 1877 (Schriften des Vereines für Socialpolitik).

On the other hand, it is not asked:
To what circumstances is the poverty of the Jewish population to be traced?
By what action (not merely by alms) might this poverty be alleviated?
How great is the number of those requiring relief, and of those requiring maintenance? &c.

These questions, moreover, could not be answered by the individuals. For that requires a searching, conscientious study, which is far harder than the drafting of memoranda and resolutions, or the convening of an "enquiry."

But one question must not be forgotten, which shines at the head of the questionnaire as the quintessence of Jewish communal wisdom. The reform of poor-relief costs money, and the religious community board has none. The maxim of the last Finance Minister, Bilinski, ran: "No new requirements without cover" — and in the Seitenstettengasse this fiscal principle meets with an understanding reception. Yet while the Finance Minister invented new taxes and made the regulation of salaries dependent upon their approval, in the religious community it is the — community members who are to rack their brains over the cover. "Whence is the money for poor-relief to be procured?" the board asks the electors in the enquiry, although it was surely called by these very electors to its honorary office only because it itself represents the quintessence of wisdom, experience, and all manner of intellectual capacities .....

The "enquiry," which means to deliberate upon poor-relief with the public excluded, without so much as hearing a single poor person, is a caricature of this social institution, a disfigurement that no one takes seriously — not even the religious community board itself. The whole aim is merely to throw dust in the electors' eyes and to create the appearance that something is being done. The very first paragraph is a little back-door for the religious community board and a trap for the Committee, through whose superficiality the entire question has been diverted from the right path. The "Committee," however, is answerable only to itself, whereas the religious community board is answerable to all the electors and to the public. Let these know what they are to make of the "Enquiry into Poor-Relief."

Dr. S. R. Landau.

The Dreyfus Miscarriage of Justice.

Since the sensational article in the "Figaro," the Dreyfus affair has taken several further decisive steps toward its solution. Mathieu Dreyfus, the brother of the condemned man, has named the true culprit, the real author of the incriminated bordereau. He is Major Walsin-Esterhazy of the 74th Infantry Regiment, garrisoned at Rouen.

Even before the formal denunciation by Mathieu Dreyfus, the "Libre Parole" had published an article signed "Dixi." This was the reply to the article in the "Figaro," which had borne the signature "Vidi." In all probability the "Dixi" is none other than Major Walsin-Esterhazy himself. It is now already beyond all doubt certain that this most singular officer — who claimed to belong to the flower of the nobility, which for its part disowns him — was one of the contributors to the journal of M. Drumont. It may before long prove no particularly flattering recommendation for the chief of the "Libre Parole" when his contributor, this worthy apostle of French antisemitism, is presented to the world in his full grandeur. But when one has had a contributor so well informed of all that passed in the foreign legations, when one was so intimately bound by common labour to a man so versed in all the secrets that were impenetrable to the gaze of ordinary humanity, then one has at least the obligation to defend such a man against the attacks of his adversaries; if not to the very end, then at least until the moment when this man appears finally disposed of. "The great prophet of the French