No. 26. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…only to read how he settled his account with the great rabbinical assembly of the forties in order to recognise how little the work of reform for the purpose of amalgamation satisfied him. If I am not mistaken, the witticism upon Hermann Holdheim, the first Berlin Jewish reformer, of Posen origin, who died of an ailment of the foot, is his. "He went too far," ran the word. In those days, when I had the pleasure of personal intercourse with Graetz, Abraham Geiger was rabbi of the Breslau congregation; between him, who lived barely a few hundred paces away in the Reuschenstrasse, and the Rabbinical Seminary there was no question of any personal relation, and it is hardly a deception of my memory if I believe that in those days the Seminary was still full of Jewish national consciousness, while Geiger combated that consciousness with mighty eloquence. The broad pathos of Geiger and the scepticism of the caustic Graetz sprang from different worlds.
Which of the two has been proved right can no longer be a matter of dispute to-day. And this too is beyond question, for me at least, that Graetz would certainly not have protested against Zionism, in which that has come to life which stirred his soul. He was the democratic citizen of the world who, without denying his national descent, would nevertheless never have thought himself, by way of a political generatio aequivoca, into the skin of a nation that was not his own. It has always seemed to me characteristic that he gave his great work the title "History of the Jews," and not, as his predecessor Jost had done, the title "History of Judaism." By this he undoubtedly meant to indicate that he regarded the Jews as a nation and not merely as a religious communion. And were he living to-day, he would, I think, cry out in holy wrath to the protesting rabbis who once sat at his feet: "Zionism shows the Jews the way home; it encourages them in the belief that they too shall one day be at home with themselves upon their own soil; if you take from the poor Jew, stripped of rights and of possessions, this hope as well, what remains to him?"
The Dreyfus Miscarriage of Justice.
(Conclusion.)
At the time of the trial the Anti-Semites were terrorising, after their fashion, the Government and the majority of the Parliament. The memory of the Panama affair was still fresh in everyone's mind. On every occasion the Anti-Semites threatened with the spectre of "certain little papers." All the world, in Parliament and elsewhere, held Drumont to be the custodian of compromising documents. Men trembled before Drumont's paper, the "Libre Parole," and have moreover not ceased to tremble even now. The fellows who had the greatest interest in ruining Dreyfus, probably in order to save the real culprit, made abundant use of this confusion of minds. The Anti-Semites possessed themselves of the affair and did not again let it out of their hands. Nay, more! The other journals, which do not exactly pursue anti-Semitism as a profession, but gladly seize an occasion to devour a Jew here and there, these too made the Dreyfus affair a Jewish one. Thus, for example, the article which Mr. Judet published in the "Petit Journal" was of far greater importance than the articles of the other journals. It owed this range to the journal which published it and which did not pass for an anti-Semitic organ, since the presence of a Jew on the board of administration, and indeed in one of the highest places, naturally did not allow such a thought to arise. Thus from the very outset a public opinion full of blindness and prepossession was created.
"Only a Jew can commit a treason; it is he who is delivered up to the vengeance of all, he upon whom every crime and infamy is cast; it is his adherence to Judaism that accuses him of the treason, that alone can console a people for having been betrayed. "It was but a few days after the arrest of Captain Dreyfus became known that all those outbursts of passion followed—at a time when nothing was yet known, when nothing could yet be known; at a time when, in the rivalry of novelties and sensational reports, the morbidly heated fancy of the reporters invented the most extravagant and improbable stories, by which chauvinism was inflamed and the sound sense of the readers befooled. Men did not so much as know the charge, and yet it was not so much as surmised that the accused might be innocent. "Never," says Bernard Lazare with justice, "was such bitterness displayed, such outbursts of passion. To him who lets these bygone occurrences pass before him, the press and the public afford the spectacle of a horde of savages performing a hideous dance about the torture-stake to which an unhappy man is bound. Men lost at that time not only the conception of justice, but also that of quite ordinary understanding, in imputing to a captain of the general staff a knowledge of all the secrets of the national defence, in appearing to believe that he held the security of the nation and the life of all in his hand and delivered them up, and that his death alone could free every man from all anxiety and from a frightful nightmare. One stands positively bewildered before such an aberration, which is without example and which has never been seen to spread in such a manner upon the news of any treason whatsoever, however monstrous it may have been. And these befooled people were afraid that their victim might perhaps escape them. During the investigation they would see undercurrents, would perceive snares and influences of every kind. They mean to save the traitor because he is a Jew, so one heard said again and again—and yet it was not yet known whether he really was a traitor. A letter which appeared at that time in the "Petit Journal" is highly characteristic in this respect. Even before the condemnation of Captain Dreyfus a reader of the "Petit Journal" wrote to that paper as follows: "As regards the punishment of traitors in China, whose terrible penalty you report to us, you add: "In France we have for traitors public degradation and the bullet. That suffices." Oh no, that does not suffice at all. Away with such softness of heart! There is unhappily too much of it in France towards criminals, and in particular towards the vile scoundrels who sell their fatherland! The penalty is too slight. Were I his judge—I, who cannot do the least hurt to an animal—I would first shut him up, like a wild beast, in an iron cage, and would then have him led past the front of several regiments on the Champ de Mars. There every officer should spit in his face. Then only the public degradation and the bullet. I repeat once more, we are too mild with the traitors in our fatherland."
"Assuredly," says Bernard Lazare, full of sorrow, "we know that human bestiality is without limits. But who will not feel the blush of shame rise into his face when he sees this savagery reveal itself thus, without those who should have been the first to hold it within bounds having known how to find a word of censure for it! On the contrary, they have even bidden it welcome, they have approved it. Nay, more! It is precisely they who have made it unbridled! It is they who befooled this multitude, which trembled with fear at the idea that it had been sold—this multitude which was soon afterwards to bellow at the innocent Captain Dreyfus the frightful words: "Into the water with him! To Satory! Death to the Jew!"—a terrible echo of the immemorial hatred which had slumbered until then in the dark depths of the conscience and of the heart. But that did not yet suffice, adds Bernard Lazare. Such demonstrations were organised as should work still more deeply upon men's minds. In Algiers anti-Semitic meetings were held, at which it was demanded that a stern justice should be exercised against Captain Dreyfus and the Jews. Rumours were spread, entirely fitted to lash the passions. The Minister of War, it was said at first, is the servant of Jewish finance. "The Jews do not cease to intrigue in order to save Dreyfus," wrote the "Libre Parole" of the 7th of November. "After all, it is the great Jewry which brought Captain Dreyfus into the Ministry of War, wholly contrary to the intentions of his superiors. It is still very questionable whether the Jews did not deliberately place Dreyfus in the position which he occupied on the general staff, in the secret hope that he would one day do what he has now actually done." And the "Patrie" and all the "patriotic" journals repeated these arguments. They pointed to the corruption which extended everywhere, over the chambers of the general staff, over the judges of the court-martial, over all those who are more or less entangled in this affair,
