Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 26.
And characteristically enough, it was precisely one of the most eminent and most amiable of German teachers of law, Otto Stobbe, who died early at Leipzig, the author of the work "The Jews in Germany," who had become a devoted friend to him at Breslau; he had laboured most unremittingly to procure for the Jewish historian a chair at the Silesian university. Strange turn of the times! Stobbe, an Aryan beyond all question, knew that Graetz was a national Jew, and yet found in that no reason to leave his friend's learning and acumen unused by German scholarship. To be sure, this was seven-and-twenty years ago, and since then how much has changed! What Stobbe to-day exerts himself for the calling of Hermann Cohen from Marburg to Berlin — Cohen, who likewise once sat at Graetz's feet in Breslau, then grew to be the foremost Kantian now living in Germany, and has nevertheless remained an undaunted professor of his faith?
Seven-and-twenty years ago, then, and for some time before and after, the German Jews revelled in the elation of their young citizenship; in every Jewish assistant judge employed on a daily allowance they saw a Minister of Justice of the near future, every Jewish sergeant-major passed with them for the herald and the guarantee of a speedy and definitive assimilation. How brief the intoxication was! At Breslau, where the university and the rabbinical seminary — the first and at that time the only one in Germany — stood side by side, this hopefulness came out with especial clearness; it was in a manner a spiritual bridge between the bank of the Oder, where the university stands, and the Wallstrasse, where the seminary is. Jacob Bernays and Hirsch Graetz taught here as there, and the seminarists divided their hours of study between the lecture-rooms yonder and these. A teacher who set the tone at the university, the Hegelian August Braniss, was a Jew by birth, sprung from a small congregation in Posen, but after his baptism he had always kept the vehemence of the turncoat far from him, and had remained on terms of kinship and intercourse with his brothers in the neighbouring place of his birth, who were orthodox teachers of the Talmud.
Graetz, who since the year 1854 had expounded Jewish history at the seminary, and, beside the aged Zacharias Frankel, Talmudic exegesis as well, was none of the many hopeful ones; with a caustic smile he once said to a gifted Jewish student of jurisprudence: "If you become Minister of Justice, mind you treat the Jews properly too." How, indeed, could he have forgotten that he came from the tiny little Posen Jew-town of Xions, where until the year 1848 a special Jew-law had made the separation between Christian and Jew felt in the most impressive manner.
And when one saw him thus, gliding hurriedly through the street, or at a certain hour of the afternoon turning over the newspapers in a confectioner's shop — Fischer and Busch, I think, it was called — one had the perfect image of a man born in the Ghetto, who never remotely thought of disowning whence he came and whither he went. The full beard and the short-curled hair, it is true, showed a lightly mingled fair; but from the middle-sized, narrow, angular figure the head bent forward, out of the yellowish-white face little quick grey eyes sparkled behind spectacles, and the hasty speech had, for all its witty dialectic, something shy, restrained, toneless about it, like that of a Ghetto Jew of former days when he found himself among the people beyond his pale. The "Bocher" Graetz could never strip from himself. He himself would relate now and then in conversation how in the year 1848 his candidature for a democratic mandate in the Prussian National Assembly had come to grief upon the insufficiency of his oratory, and how for the same reason he had quickly abandoned the career of preacher on which he had entered. To this he was wont to attach the general reflection that the pressure which lay upon the Jews of the German East before the year 1848, in company with the peculiar Talmudic method of discourse, had hindered the development of public eloquence among them. And it is true that the Jewish orators of the time before and after March were not of eastern origin; Gabriel Riesser, the enthrallingly eloquent vice-president of the Paulskirche, was a Hamburger, Abraham Geiger a Frankforter, Isaak Mannheimer was from Sweden. Yet when one considers that Eduard Simson, the classic parliamentary orator, the two brothers Heinrich and Ludwig Simon, the distinguished speakers of the Frankfort and Berlin National Assemblies, and after them Ferdinand Lassalle, all of them born Jews, came from Koenigsberg and Breslau, then surely the occupation with the Talmud from earliest youth was of itself essentially sufficient to prevent the art of speech from arising. Not as though occupation with the Talmud stifled eloquence altogether; it is only the art of public speech that is crushed by it. A Pischat, a Drasche is spoken otherwise than a political speech or an academic festival address. It is a veritable whirling dance of syntheses and antitheses, of premises and objections, of conclusions and syllogisms, accompanied by a stereotyped rising and falling melody of speech, by movements of the head and of the right hand which reinforce the dialectical effect. The four great rabbis of the East, whose teaching influence still reached down to the year 1848 — Rabbi Akiba Eger in Posen, the Rabbi of Lissa, Rabbi Mordochai Benet in Nikolsburg, and Rabbi Moses Sofer in Pressburg — were one and all no orators, but heads of schools in the old Talmudic sense.
Thus Graetz too was thrown back upon research and discovery in the study; but that he did not thereby lose touch with public life was seen to by the immense many-sidedness of his mind. To be sure, the man who in politics stood always on the side of the most advanced liberalism had no need of the illusion of assimilation, and he never gave himself up to it; yet he was none the less deeply embittered at its consummate bankruptcy, when anti-Semitic brutality possessed itself of the masses by its agitation and found proselytes with headlong success in society and in the offices of the bureaucrats. Not long before his death — he died in the year 1891 — Graetz was in Vienna. In the wrinkles of his face, in his deeply bowed figure, the gnawing anguish of soul revealed itself; something had broken within him, one read it in his sad eye, as one had read it also in the look of Berthold Auerbach, who in the year 1848 had likewise found a refuge in Breslau and later literally pined away beneath the collapse of his German-nationalizing hopes. In Breslau, indeed, anti-Semitism had shot up especially early and especially wildly, and over the gateway of the Zwinger, the merchants' club, it had five-and-twenty years ago already posted the placard: "Jews and dogs forbidden to enter." But brave and confident Graetz had remained through it all: wrapped in his fur, shivering, with head deeply bowed, the man of nearly seventy walked at that time on a late autumn evening beside me — I too being for the moment in Vienna — along the Ringstrasse, and what he spoke was half ground out between his teeth and half — exulted. I set nothing down in writing, but to this day the impression of that conversation is alive in me, to which he gave again and again the turn: Now at last we shall surely see that we belong together, that we are thrown back upon none but ourselves, that no constitution and no law can guarantee us what we do not, fighting as a close-knit stock, win for ourselves.
And whatever his pupils, the Güdemanns and Vogelsteins, Rahmers and Guttmanns, may say, the national-Jewish confession of their teacher, who towered above them all, they will not call in question. It is laid down in the great work of his life. Searching and seeking, divining and finding, he suffered with all that through the millennia of history has been wrought upon the Jews, and one has