Paris Letter.
By A. Ludvipol.
It is a general delusion to assert that, since the emancipation of the Jews in France, anti-Semitism has entirely disappeared. That is a claim founded on mere appearance, which by no means holds up when one gets to the bottom of the matter. True it is only that Jew-hatred in France, during the nineteenth century, did not pass beyond the sphere of literature. This is a form that M. Bernard Lazare has rightly designated antisemitisme scripturaire. Could Jew-hatred, for that matter, ever vanish entirely from the soul of the French people? By no means! For there is a general cause that produces anti-Semitism always and everywhere — namely, the dispersion of Israel. In France the Jew, just as everywhere in other lands, is regarded as a foreigner, an intruder. After the proclamation of the ideas of liberty, equality, and fraternity, the French could not let their feelings against the Jews turn into deeds without displaying a contradiction between their ideas and their actions. These feelings of an instinctive antagonism toward us — feelings of atavistic origin — must find their limit in a propaganda by the word alone. Even if we leave the clerical and ultramontane press quite unmentioned — which has never ceased to wage the bitterest war against the Jews, whom it made responsible for the gradual decline of the authority of throne and altar — we can name several writers of repute who, in the course of our century, have handled us Jews very roughly in their writings. Some of them declared open war on us, as for instance Toussenel in his work The Jews — Kings of Our Age, and the brothers Goncourt in their novel Manette Salomon. Others dealt us a slap only in passing. The baleful influence of these latter is perhaps even greater than that of the former — all the more so as even those French writers who passed for friends of the Jews are not wholly to be acquitted of having, in one way or another, spoken ill of us. A typical example is Renan. Yes, even the great Renan! In defending the thesis of the spiritual inferiority of the Jewish people, he too doubtless contributed his share to the anti-Semitic movement. I have at least heard that said fairly often by Catholics.
Indisputable, to be sure, is that there has been no anti-Semitic propaganda of the deed in France. Thus there have, for instance, been no uprisings against the Jews — unless we choose to reckon the uprising that took place in Alsace in the year 1848.
To make the step from theory to practice, anti-Semitism had to begin, too, among the Jews of Algeria. Anti-Semitism in Algiers followed exactly the same course as that in Austria. By way of elections it seized the municipal administrations. From there it seeks gradually to penetrate the Senate and the Chamber, in expectation of the great electoral battle next year, for which it is preparing energetically and impetuously. I will not predict the outcome of this battle; but I should not be at all astonished if Drumont and his people remained the victors in it. Meanwhile anti-Semitism provokes riots against the Jews in Algiers, whose baleful consequences have already made themselves felt repeatedly.
But in France itself, too, anti-Semitism is making efforts to pass from words to the deed. For the moment it has not yet gained excessive ground there, whereas down below, on African soil, it has already carried off the victory, or at least is no longer far from it. Now superficial observers would ascribe the successes of anti-Semitism in Algeria to the tacit support which the governor-general of the colony, M. Cambon, has hitherto granted it. Without denying the baleful role that Cambon has played in the development of the anti-Semitic movement in Algiers, I believe I come nearer the truth in asserting that the governor's attitude was a direct consequence of the situation of the colony, at least in political respects. That situation was one of the most effective causes of the advances of anti-Semitism.
In Algeria two great political parties are just now locked in struggle with one another: the Moderates and the Radicals. The radical party groups about itself the adherents of all extreme views — of Socialism, of anti-Semitism, and so on. We shall see how this radical party has not merely concluded an alliance with the anti-Semites but has itself, and indeed completely, become anti-Semitic.
After the war of 1870/71 the political situation was by no means the same as today. One knows Gambetta's battle-cry: "Clericalism — there is the enemy!" The republican party had to fight against the reactionary. The one as well as the other split into factions of various coloring. But these factions were all agreed with one another as soon as it was a matter of the great questions of principle. The Right and the Left — that was the great division of the parties. In Algiers the political situation was the same as in France. Radicals and Moderates together formed the great liberal, progressive-republican party against the Reaction. In those days the Jews were allied with the Republicans against the Reaction. The Radicals were therefore friends of the Jews with the same right as the Moderates. But, but — the times change. As soon as the common enemy, the reactionary party, was significantly weakened numerically and morally, the quarrels within the republican party became manifest. Right and Left, to be sure, still sulk at one another. But the Left Center approaches quite gently the Center of the Right, while the extreme Left flirts with the extreme Right. One scarcely hears any longer the old battle-cry: "Clericalism — there is the enemy!"
Or rather, when it still sometimes resounds beneath the vaults of the Palais Bourbon, it happens no longer with the same force, the same vehemence, and the same fury as in the good old days of the heroic political struggles, but sounds only like an echo of bygone days. On the one side now stands the Left Center — that is, the Moderates, the Opportunists — with the Right Center, with the ralliés, and with those who, more or less officially, more or less voluntarily, have rallied to the present government in order, together with it, to combat most emphatically the "collectivist monster," the "social revolution." The extreme Left, it is true, reproaches the Left Center with denying the very principles of the revolution when it enters into a more or less avowed alliance with the Right. On the other hand, however, the extreme Left never refuses the aid of the extreme Right, which likewise longs for a revolution — the reactionary one, namely. Thus the radical ministry, which was led by Bourgeois, availed itself not only of the aid of the Collectivists but was supported also by the clerical anti-Semites of the extreme Right.
However that may be, it is undeniable that today it is no longer a matter of the great struggle between the united Republic and the Reaction. Now the electoral battle, as M. Barthou declared only recently in his program-speech at Bayonne,