No. 19. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
…leads off the round. "Cosmopolis" brings, from Langwill's pen, "Impressions of the Congress". In the "Asiatic Quarterly Review" Dr. Gaster gives, under the title "The Return of the Jews to Palestine and the Zionist Movement", a historical account of the Zionist idea and sets forth its political significance for the Powers; finally Mr. Herbert Bentwich replies, in an article "Philo-Zionists and Anti-Semites", to the attacks of Dr. Emil Reich which appeared some time ago in the same review under the title "Zionism", and takes the occasion to develop his own views of the Zionist movement.
Dr. Gaster traces the history of the Zionist idea back to its beginnings, as they find expression in our prayer-book. When those prayers were composed, the return to Palestine was conceived as a self-evident consequence of the golden Messianic age; and in the same spirit in which they were composed they were also understood by the pious fathers throughout Jewry. This hope was so far removed from the present, so far from any possibility of fulfilment, that the utmost to which the optimism of a Jew could rise was a grave in holy ground. With the coming of the modern emancipation of the Jews, the old poetic relation to the Promised Land was altered. "The emancipated Jews attached themselves body and soul to the culture of the lands in which they lived. For a time it looked as though Israel would be absorbed among the nations. — Zion seemed forgotten. But the revival of the national idea, which dates from the beginning of our century, reminded the Jews too that they are a people. To this was added the persecuting fury of modern anti-Semitism, which in a great part of Europe threatened the Jews in their social and economic position, indeed in life and limb itself. That naturally did not a little to awaken their national feeling. But anti-Semitism had yet a further consequence. The Jews were faced with the necessity of seeking new fields for their industry and their eagerness for action. The idea of Jewish colonisation was born. The emigrants turned their eyes to Palestine; some fifteen years ago, with the support of Dr. Gaster among others, the first Jewish colony in Palestine was founded. The colonies in the Holy Land have shown a gratifying prosperity from the outset; similar attempts on other soil have failed. From this it follows that settlement in Palestine is an inescapable necessity. But gradual colonisation is of no use to us; it would postpone the solution of the question by at least three hundred years. Real help, however, is brought by Dr. Herzl's Jewish State.
Dr. Gaster understands Herzl's plan to mean that we should acquire Palestine for ourselves in much the same manner as England acquired Cyprus from Turkey. The island is administered by England, but in international law belongs to Turkey, and England has to render that Power an annual tribute. In like manner we should acquire Palestine from Turkey without withdrawing it from the suzerainty of the Sultan, and we should pay an annual tribute proportioned to the revenues of the State. In return our autonomy would be secured to us, under the protection of Turkey. That Power has always treated the Jews in friendly fashion; they have full confidence in it and feel entirely secure under Turkish protection. Dr. Gaster reckons that three million Jews would be found ready to emigrate to Palestine, once the guarantees for that autonomy were in existence. The first immigrants would not belong precisely to the poorest classes; there would even be some very rich among them; but in the majority they would be recruited from the middle class — artisans, farmers and similar strata. The only financial assistance we need is an advance for the tribute to be rendered; repayment would be made out of the revenues of the State. This advance is, according to Dr. Gaster, easy to procure. There are capital funds, he says, which have come into being through collections and legacies and have for their purpose the support of needy Jews, in particular such as are stricken by the persecutions in the East. When those men to whom the administration of these funds is entrusted come to see — and they will come to see it, and that soon — that our movement is irresistible and promises to bring about the very results towards which they themselves have been labouring, then they will furnish the money for the advance which is to serve for the founding of the Jewish State.
The prosperity of this State stands beyond all doubt, and we have more than that to expect of it; it will become a centre of intellectual life. A university is in Jerusalem with Jewish professors, such as are now active in the universities of Europe, will easily bear comparison with any European university.
And a Jewish State in Palestine means a great gain not for the Jews alone: the Eastern question would take a new turn through this creation, and one need hardly be reminded what value Palestine must have for that great Eastern Power which commands the Suez Canal and Egypt.
Exceedingly interesting is Zangwill's essay upon the Congress — not as though it brought new thoughts or opened new points of view, but it bears witness to the enthralling power of the movement, from which even reluctant spirits, pessimists and mocking doubters of Zangwill's stamp can no longer withdraw themselves. The famous English novelist did not come precisely as a friend; English and German papers had circulated in his name all manner of hostile utterances, and there is no doubt that he appeared at the first sitting of the Congress indifferent, cool to the very heart. Zangwill was plainly concerned to get a human document, a literary study, a new picture for his gallery of "Dreamers of the Ghetto". In the course of the proceedings he became another man: the events of the Congress made of the scoffer a warm eulogist and an enthusiastic champion of our hopes.
"By the rivers of Babylon we sat down and wept, yea, we wept when we remembered thee, O Zion. By the river of Babylon we sit, resolved to weep no more."
An opening that does not exactly accord with the gravity of the Basle event, and therefore warrants no particularly friendly expectations. But that is an error. We can communicate only a few striking passages from Zangwill's essay, but these will suffice completely to show the famous writer as a friend of the Zionist movement.
"A strangely assorted company, these leaders, but all with the ink-mark on the brow which on the Continent is the badge of energy, as in England it stands for the emblem of barrenness; all penetrated by the naïve belief that the pen is mightier than the millionaire's gold.
One of them has indeed moved the world with his pen-point, a prophet of the modern age, with the cry of woe of psycho-physiology; himself fresh, brimming with strength, far removed from degeneration; the great grey head is packed full of facts and languages; he has a golden heart and a golden mouth, an orator who can conjure forth tears or laughter with equal facility. A striking contrast to this quasi-Teutonic figure is formed by the lion's head of the Russian leader with its black mane, an Apollo in the part of a berserker, magnificent, overwhelming, from whose splendid mouth the barbaric words roll like thunder in the mountains.
And even as no two among the leaders resemble one another, so no likeness is to be found among the individuals in the mass either. Writers and journalists, poets and story-tellers, professors, physicians, jurists — people who once sought to slip out of their Jewish skin and, on Darwinian principles, to take on the colours of their surroundings, but who now either in