Page 4. — "Die Welt." — No. 15.
(continued from page 3)
… from Transjordania swell were to be held in reservoirs, then "by artificial irrigation cultivation might be pushed ever further into the desert." Desert and waste would become a "place of delight, the steppe would break into rejoicing and blossom as the rose." — The old aggadic saying concerning the wonderful elasticity of our holy soil would be confirmed to the letter.
I endorse fully and entirely the theses set forth by Dr. Schnirer in his report upon the system of practical colonisation hitherto pursued, theses which I myself, on the ground of my own observation, have already expressed in speech and in writing.
-
Without prejudice to the existing colonies, which of course must be maintained so far as it is expedient, the work of colonisation as hitherto conducted stands in need of a radical and incisive reform. Not a step towards new colonising enterprises before a secured legal status has been created for them! The sharp but perfectly justified criticism which Dr. Schnirer directed against the prevailing system of baksheesh will have to be subscribed to without any reservation by every one acquainted with the conditions. All parties concerned, the Turkish officials in question as well as the Jewish intermediaries, are utterly corrupted by this baksheesh abuse. It has been intimated to me that the Jewish colonies now existing are by no means to be undervalued as agricultural experimental stations. But one may not experiment overlong with the weal and woe of some 1000 family existences; and in any case high-minded and wealthy patrons would be able to serve precisely this phase of the cause of Zion far more expediently and with far more sense of purpose by establishing scientifically directed and well-appointed estate farms than has hitherto been done.
-
No system of administration and tutelage in the actual practical work of colonisation, but free co-operative labour under a single, democratically constituted central direction. Together with the regulation and supervision of immigration and settlement on the part of such a central direction.
A word upon the "Zion Central Committee," which organised itself at Paris in January 1894. It was intended at the outset that this Committee should direct the whole work of colonisation. For a certain reason which does not lend itself to publication, its activity was in the end restricted to the establishment of the labourers' colony Kastinie, and to the support, or rather the reorganisation, of Mischmar Hajarden in common with the J. C. A. Efforts are now being directed towards settling lands already purchased elsewhere with those of our people resident in Palestine, above all with pupils from Mikwe-Israel, but also with Jewish agricultural labourers and with a great part of the urban Jewish youth of Jerusalem, Safed, Tiberias, Damascus, and so forth, whose dearest wish it is to till the land to fruitfulness.
Here it must also be emphasised that among the colonists not standing under the patronage of the Russian Chowewei Zion Committee the French spirit prevails too far, a spirit not precisely calculated to redound to the profit and advantage of Zionism.
In the settlements too whose founding the J. C. A. has lately held out in prospect, this un-Jewish spirit will presumably continue to administer as before. Nor can the present relation of dependence in which most of the colonists stand contribute towards forming a sound, vigorous, free, and independent Jewish peasantry.
The incapacity of the "Zion Central Committee" to play the leading part in the movement has the following grounds:
-
Since the members of the Committee reside in Paris, London, and Berlin, and the Russian representative must first obtain counsel from Odessa before every important resolution, the operation of the Committee is the most cumbrous conceivable. Every member has moreover his private calling as well, which absorbs the best of his time and the best of his powers, and only in his hours of leisure can he occupy himself with the labours of the Committee.
-
Notwithstanding that the mode of election prescribes that 3 members not resident in Paris must have seat and voice in the Committee, the composition of the Committee is nevertheless to be described as thoroughly arbitrary and undemocratic, and that because the preponderating influence of the Paris representatives permits of no open, free action clear to all Zionists. 3 or 4 gentlemen in Paris, and the like number in Jaffa, and in the majority of cases only the latter, decide in the end upon the particular application of the moneys, and to the masses who furnish the money no account whatever, or a most incomplete and generalising one, is rendered. Upon the character of the undertakings, too, these have little say.
From what has been depicted above there follow with inexorable logic the following truths, to be laid to heart by a true and rightful Zionist organisation.
-
Its Central Committee must be composed of men who devote their whole time and strength to the central direction. No Sport-Zionists! — The Zionist organisation has, if need be, to allot these men an honorarium.
-
The central direction must not be an oligarchical one, but must be democratically constituted and responsible to the Congress in all essentials.
The description of the Chaluka system and of Jewish schooling I leave to my friend Dr. Heinrich Loewe, who has lately looked closely into these matters in Palestine. I will only remark thus much, that the Chaluka must on no account be abolished so long as nothing better has been put in its place. But a reform of the Chaluka is urgently required.
In this connection I will still adduce in passing a few data upon the condition of the Jewish workers at Jerusalem, for which I am indebted chiefly to my friend Wilhelm Gross, commission agent in Jaffa and Jerusalem. During the last two decades the number of Jewish workmen and artisans there has increased considerably in consequence of the newer colonisation movement, so that the supply of labour now far exceeds the demand. Of some 2000 families that here come into consideration, scarcely 400 find scanty employment. The misery resulting therefrom may be vividly imagined. A remedy is of course possible only through the creation of opportunities for work, whereby the reform of the Chaluka would also be considerably furthered. Therefore, in the first rank, the multiplication of the branches of industry already existing. Many raw products, or merely half-manufactured goods, are exported to Europe instead of being worked up in the country into marketable articles. Labour is cheap in Palestine, and the land offers a wide field for profitable investments of capital. The development of industry and commerce in Palestine is extraordinarily promising.
The following motions, brought forward by Messrs. Gross and Bambus, may be submitted here in the form of suggestions:
-
The appointment of a commission of experts from various countries to examine the existing Chaluka system and the condition of the Palestinian workers, and, upon the ground of their report, an agreement if possible with the Palestine Societies and the J. C. A. respecting the realisation of the reform to be undertaken.
-
As a preparatory step towards attaining that secured legal status which is absolutely indispensable to the colonisation of Palestine, a legal protection authority (composed of European Zionists acquainted with Turkish law) should be created.
Upon the point of Palestinian export and import the following is suggested:
