Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 11 · 13 August 1897
2printed page
scan 6 of 20

Page 2. — "Die Welt" — No. 11.

(continued from page 1)

… look about for holding-points, for lofty rocks, as it were, to which he may cling fast when once he comes to wreck upon the surging sea of his feelings. The two parts demand and complete one another: the sea requires the rock, and sensuality the holy asceticism, the madness of the stylite. For this reason, too, the ecclesiastical organisation, the hierarchy, will be the more elaborated, the finer and the more pliant, the darker the forces and the storms of temper which it has to guide and to bridle. But the stronger the hierarchy is, the more independent and the more self-seeking it also is, and the more it must come into conflict with the counter-organisation of the State. This is a circulus vitiosus. The religious demagogue rises up against the State, which calls the prince of the Church to its aid. The prince of the Church does indeed bridle the demagogue, but for that he requires a whole series of instruments of power which reach over into the competence of the State. These typical forms of the ecclesiastico-political struggle Christianity has, as already said, brought to a peculiarly sharp expression, because its entire development drove straight towards such a conflict.

With sure instinct all the generations of these nineteen centuries past have pointed to the prophets, to Isaiah, to Jeremiah, who were to be in every respect the forerunners and heralds of Jesus Christ. At the least, in the old Palestine of those days the life of instinct and feeling, the fearful vehemence of sensation, had been driven to a pitch such as was afterwards reached only in Christianity. The drunken, frenzied service of Baal which broke in upon Israel corresponded to this condition of a boundlessly exalted sensuality. But the prophets stood in the storm of the waves like rocks, and strove after the curbing and the bridling of the evil impulses. Their means of struggle and of organisation they took, it is true, from the ruling State-church, yet at bottom they made something wholly different out of them. They rejected, for example, the cult of sacrifice, which in antiquity was the domain from which the State fetched its religious relations. Not incense and sacrifice did the God of the prophets desire, but humility, contrition, purity of heart. In other words, the prophets addressed themselves far less to the political body of the people than precisely to the individual, with whose demonic impulses they wrestled, in order to force him down and then again to raise him up — up to God. This end outweighed with them every other consideration, even the consideration of the politics and the political greatness of their people. Occasional collisions with the royal power did indeed occur; and had the prophets succeeded in gaining a lasting influence upon the destinies of the nation, there would presumably have arisen already in Palestine a Pope who hurled sentences of excommunication against refractory kings. So far, however, it did not come, and at most it was as a voice out of the grave that the dead Samuel terrified the apostate King Saul. There were good grounds for it when Judaism, even at the height of its religious development, did not proceed to the last step, to the supra-political hierarchy above the State. Everything the old Jews already possessed which Christianity afterwards bore in itself: the melancholy, the capacity for the most frightful martyrdom, and the fanaticism. One thing, however, and that is the essential core of Christianity, they did not possess at all — not the metaphysics, not the sensuous-supersensuous dream of the beyond.

If one may put faith in the historian Grätz and in other students of the Bible, the Fourth Book of Maccabees arose in the first years of the Christian era. It contains the narrative of the mother and the seven children who were butchered under torments by the Syrians because they refused the service of idols. A martyrdom is therefore depicted which at bottom could spring only from an extravagant heroic exaltation, from a hideous lashing-up of all the instincts. But why, to what end, is this history told us? In majorem gloriam rationis humanae! The narrator was polemising against the Apostle Paul, who rejected the "Law," that product of a systematising understanding, and doubted that man could ever of his own strength free himself from his impulses. "The spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak," Paul had mocked; and his adversary now wished to prove that the human reason, that is to say the spirit, is not only willing but also strong enough to compel the weak flesh. Accordingly the through and through political, rationalistic principle of the free will is set up, and the understanding is required, by its logic and its law, to wrest from the flesh — that is to say, from the life of instinct — the most monstrous things. When a people, before the spectacle of its own martyrdom and its own deeds of heroism, arrives at no more than such reflections, then one must surely say that the metaphysical sense is wanting to it, that it has no inclination to brood over the linking of man with the universe, over the whole riddle of existence, until it ventures to divine the riddle's solution darkly only in the unearthly and the mysterious. No, and to what purpose? The human will, regulated by reason and by law, is after all capable of everything. But since the will always seeks activity as well, the old Jewish national spirit soon found itself directed back to the practical, political domain, and along the whole line the assault of the prophets was beaten back. The State took the matter into its hands again, and in the post-exilic time, under Ezra and Nehemiah, it did in fact succeed, by a strict discipline, in quieting the exalted tempers. The Jewish people now went wholly and entirely into the theocracy, and religion and polity covered one another completely. That, however, was by no means a Jewish peculiarity alone, but a characteristic mark of political life in classical antiquity. In Egypt too, in Rome, in Athens, in Carthage, the priesthood and the sacrificial system were above all a component part of the bureaucracy of the State. Nowhere, however, did the hierarchy at that time form a real State within the State and make life hard for the politician. Beginnings of it did indeed show themselves: in Egypt, in Etruria, and finally in Palestine itself, in the time of the prophets. But these beginnings did not develop, and it was reserved for the Christian Middle Ages first to bring about the struggle between State and Church, which later had the individualising of morals and manners for its unforeseen consequence. Max Stirner therefore hit the nail on the head when he set the Jews in one group with the Greeks and Romans and designated them, as it were, the surviving scion of antiquity. In fact the Jewish ceremonial law, for example, has far more kinship with the pedantic deportment of the Greek and Roman Stoics than with the ascetic madness of the anchorites, of the flagellant monks, and of Simon Stylites, who all strove systematically after unearthly and overflowing exaltations of feeling. Here precisely lies the difference between political and individual morality. Politicians the old Jews always remained, even though with them, to be sure, the exuberance of feeling often threatened to burst the political vessel, and sometimes did burst it. But since all saving metaphysics and dialectic were completely wanting to them, they saw themselves compelled to forge the political hoop together again, ever harder and closer the more violent the assaults from without became — closest and hardest in the most terrible Middle Ages with its appalling butcheries of Jews. For the Jews of the Middle Ages, too, were nothing further than a political theocracy in scattered remnants. And it was not from religious but from national grounds that the "bridle of the laws" was created. It aimed at nothing further than the preservation of the national character in a stormy time. Naturally this condition of a perpetual armament was felt to be very hard and