No. 9. — Page 5.
(continued from page 4)
… wants out of Egypt, would flatly renounce Syria into the bargain as well. If there were no other point of contention in the partition, this little scrap of Syria would suffice to kindle a proper world war.
* * *
The "short overland route to India" — that is the most remarkable phrase in the article of the "Quarterly Review". England needs this short route, so to speak, as she needs her daily bread. The Suez Canal is already to-day a route to India outstripped by technical possibilities. That is astonishing enough, but so it is. England's world-encompassing policy has immense interconnections. Russia's Siberian railway is a fearful blow to England's Asiatic interests. The line is not yet finished, and England trembles before it already, and with reason. She cries out for a "short overland route to India". That route leads — no other leads to India — straight across Palestine to the Persian Gulf. But not only England knows this; other Powers know it too. The Suez Canal was at first not rightly understood in Europe — what a consolation for the reviled and ridiculed seekers of new ways — in England above all men set themselves against Lesseps' grandiose work. But to-day the colonial understanding of Europeans has reached another degree of ripeness. To-day a quite particular attention will be given to the "short overland route to India", which looks so harmless. We had occasion lately, in considering Leroy-Beaulieu's book, to establish that the French desire Syria, and desire it urgently. This precious "short route" no Great Power can or will grudge to another. Perhaps, however, they will agree to leave the function of establishing a short route to a small neutral political formation which can establish itself in Palestine and which, out of sheer weakness, would be an obstacle to nobody. That would truly be a solution of the difficulties, not least for Turkey — and most of all for the Jews at last made settled.
* * *
A short notice ran through the papers: the German Emperor intends shortly to go to Jerusalem. Should this journey be traced back to the suggestion of the "short route"? Upon the shortest way to India much has been found for mankind: the coasts of Africa were explored, America was discovered, the Isthmus of Suez was cut through. Upon the shortest way to India lies perhaps also the solution of the Jewish question.
* * *
In Herr v. Suttner's article in our last number the misgiving was expressed that an immigration of Jews into Palestine might awaken anti-Semitism there also. Certainly — if it took place without guarantees obtained beforehand. That is precisely why the political Zionists are against the attempt of the philanthropic ones to send the poor Jews thither just so, without more ado. Without sufficient protection under the law of nations we will not set the movement afoot; we should hold that to be the most dangerous, the most frivolous of experiments. The Powers concerned in the Jewish question will take counsel with themselves whether they will and should solve, together with the Jewish question, a portion of the Eastern one. Whether it would not mean the establishment of inward peace in many a European land and at the same time of order in a neglected corner of the Orient, if the proposal of the Zionists were accepted. That would indeed be a short route to many good things.
New York Letter.
By Michael Singer.
Middle of July 1897.
Dr. Pereira Mendes, the rabbi of the Portuguese congregation here, who at the outset identified himself with Zionism but afterwards held himself rather aloof from the movement, addressed to me these days a private letter in which he communicates to me his views upon Zionism. Dr. Mendes, who is unquestionably a considerable mind and a warm-hearted Jew, seems — I infer this from his letter — to harbour the apprehension that the Jewish State to be founded will be built upon a socialistic foundation. For the rest he pays homage to Zionism, which — I quote his own words — deserves every encouragement. The pious man of God desires, to be sure, that the movement remain in accord with the teachings of Holy Scripture.
Of importance is a passage of the said letter which fairly astounded me. According to that passage, the resolutions of the Board of Jewish Ministers of the city of New-York, upon which I have already reported to you, were launched into the press in a falsified form by the opponents of the movement.
Dr. Mendes informs me, namely, that the rabbinical conference in a resolution conceded the justification for the formation of a Jewish State, but attached thereto the remark that the Jews always were and are good citizens of their adopted fatherland. A remark to which every Zionist subscribes, for it is precisely the Zionist's complaint that the Jew is a good citizen, but as such is not recognised. — We Zionists go, as is well known, even further; we desire, namely, that the Jews may in the future also remain good citizens of that land in which the citizens are granted full civic rights as well.
It appears, however, as though most of our Jewish brethren in America were in the dark concerning the essence of Zionism. This holds good especially of our English-speaking brethren, who get to see only those papers in which unscrupulous rabbinical apostles of incitement distort Zionism and seek to impute base motives to the leaders of the movement. For this reason it would truly be needful to found a Zionist organ in the English language, in order on the one hand to spoil the trade of these apostles of incitement, and on the other — which must surely be the chief matter — to show Zionism in its true and glorious shape. We are also seriously entertaining the intention of founding an English paper beside the "Toleranz". Of course that is not to be done in the twinkling of an eye.
Among our German-speaking brethren the movement is growing in gratifying fashion. The "Choweve Zion" held a meeting last Sunday in the Eldridge Street Synagogue, which was attended by over 2000 persons. The speakers carried the hearers away.
For Monday I had convoked, in the name of the Central Union of American Zionists, a mass meeting at Liberty Hall, in order to bring to a reading the appeal of Dr. Theodor Herzl that had been sent to me. Despite the prevailing blazing heat the hall was packed full, and deep suspense was painted upon every face when the chairman, Rabbi Kopfstein, declared in his opening address that at the close of the meeting the appeal of Dr. Herzl would be read as the pièce de resistance. The gentlemen Julius Gottlieb and Jos. Rappaport officiated as speakers, enthusiastic Zionists whose words, coming from the heart, visibly penetrated to the hearts of the hearers.
Afterwards I received the floor, in order, after a somewhat lengthy introduction, to read the appeal. Thunderous applause lasting minutes accompanied the reading of the appeal. The enthusiasm would take no end. Dr. Herzl's appeal now forms the talk of the day in Jewish circles, and this appeal will in a few days appear in print in German, English, and Jargon, and be distributed.
A Zionist organisation founded in Brooklyn these days will hold its first mass meeting on Tuesday, the 13th of July. Likewise, Zion societies are coming into being in several cities of the State of New Jersey.
For the Congress an uncommonly lively interest makes itself manifest. Not only will the United States be represented; Canada too will send representatives to Basle, and Montreal in particular, where the American rabbis are at present holding their deliberations, seems by the sending of delegates to wish to make a demonstration against certain rabbis.