Page 2. — Die Welt — No. 8.
I know that this is a very delicate question, yet I think it should and must be touched upon. If Zionism pursues merely the purpose of gathering Jewry together in order to remove it from the reach of its oppressors, then of course it is a matter for later natural development how things will shape themselves in Palestine. But I see yet another purpose before me, namely this: to found a model state, across whose borders the dissolute, wretched conditions of old Europe may not pass; a break with everything that in these lands still passes for a sacred necessity and that, looked at more closely, harbours within itself the most pernicious germs of cancer.
And for that reason I should have welcomed with greater joy proposals concerning the building of a Urania, concerning the establishment and equipment of institutions of popular education, of familistères and the like.
Certainly, to erect a state in this form, upon an entirely new foundation, is a prodigiously difficult piece of work. The largest contingent will not be furnished by the intelligentsia; rather, the mass influx will come out of those little Galician, Russian and Roumanian nests where men have lost their human self-awareness in poverty and want of education, and where they have been accustomed by their oppressors to seek their consolation in other than earthly regions. Unhappily this will be so, and therein the present exodus will differ greatly from that of old Biblical days. The Old Testament has nothing to tell of Jews who let their poor comrades go and calmly stayed behind because they would not exchange their comfortable existence for an uncertain nomad life of toil and privation. On the contrary: from the chapters on the ordering and furnishing of the Tabernacle, on the offerings, &c., it appears plainly that there took part in the migration such also as were in a position to lay gold and jewels in abundance upon the altar.
I should not wish to be misunderstood, nor even to awaken the suspicion that a mass exodus would be desirable to me. On the contrary: I have remarked it in a letter to Dr. Herzl, and I repeat it here expressly, that in my conviction a total exodus of the Jews out of Europe would have the ruin of Europe for its consequence. But I am indeed of the opinion that those who lead an existence free from care, and who are consequently far less touched by the prevailing currents, should accompany their comrades at least in spirit, and in this form: that they contribute that gold which is indispensable for the securing of such an undertaking. Further, that they should set themselves toward a movement which has assuredly sprung from a purely ethical, humane idea in a spirit of friendly help and moral furtherance — and not of hostility. That we have, God help us, a Jewish question is just as certain as that it must be solved. Here, however, there are but two means: either measures of force on the part of the natural and obligated protector, the State, for the defence of the oppressed; or else — exodus.
What we have to expect from this legally appointed protector he has shown us sufficiently in the course of the last years; one may therefore pass without more ado to the order of the day upon the first point and take the second into deliberation. Exodus! Even so! How can one demand that those in whose faces the word "aliens" is daily flung should feel love for the soil upon which they lead a wretched existence, and that there should kindle in their hearts what men call "patriotism"! Patience and forbearance are fine virtues, but they have their limits. One need be no vengeful, no bad man to feel aversion toward those who deliberately do one injury; it is a feeling as natural as love. And aversion toward the individuals naturally brings with it that one feels antipathy also toward that which stands in closer relation to them. The poor hawker or old-clothes Jew, with a rabble of coarse lads at his heels raising the Hepp—Hepp cry, is he to cherish patriotic feelings? Toward whom? Toward his persecutors — or toward the street where this befalls him — or toward the authority that willingly shuts an eye — or toward the State that tolerates such things?
And precisely these little ones — the little in social station and the little in years (for the Jewish schoolboys too have to suffer under similar persecutions) — are the unhappiest, for upon them "Aryan" courage can celebrate its orgies with the least danger. Especially the young, with their soft, susceptible hearts, which feel the good — but the evil also — in tenfold measure, especially these must be embittered and filled with hatred in their earliest years; and we cannot demand that patriots shall grow up there who are ready one day to sacrifice goods and blood for those by whom they have been hunted as by bloodhounds. With such a demand we should only be rearing falsehood and hypocrisy.
Why, then, does an opposition arise in the ranks of the Jews themselves against this, that those who can no longer endure such conditions should take up the pilgrim's staff? It is unintelligible to me. And precisely the circumstance that this antagonism is voiced particularly in one section of the Jewish priesthood leads one to the surmise that in these circles it is feared to see the power over these souls pass into other, into secular hands. This would be once again the struggle for the supremacy of the Church, to the detriment of millions of unhappy beings who thirst for deliverance and redemption out of the Egyptian captivity.
Or should — I would rather believe it — nobler misgivings be in play here, such as the anxiety that the undertaking may miscarry and that the many who fancy they are coming into the Promised Land may there find their destruction? This anxiety is superfluous if the undertaking is secured from the outset. Nothing is needed for that but money, prodigiously much money, and good will, above all the will to remain united. The most dangerous enemy is disunion; upon it the best, the fairest undertaking founders. Where many heads and many minds rule, the cause is lost beforehand.
And as concerns the sovereignty of the Sultan — well, there many a misgiving might be uttered. A man in whose land the Armenian massacres were possible does not seem to me the most trustworthy guarantor for the tranquillity of the Jews. During my long residence in the Orient I had occasion to observe the Armenian question — that too is a question — in its first germination; simultaneously with the rise of anti-Semitism in the north and the west, anti-Armenianism grew great, and the movement is exactly one and the same: the Armenian is the working, creating, earning and intelligent element in contrast to the indolent Oriental — call him Turk, Mingrelian, Georgian or Kurd. Hence the hatred, the declaring of men outlaws, which a worthy Austrian Jew-hater has urgently recommended for our country also. A spreading of the Jewish element in Palestine would possibly offer fresh nourishment to Oriental fanaticism and transform anti-Armenianism into anti-Semitism.
Then indeed Dr. Nordau would be right when he cries: "Plough and Sword!" But a fairer watchword, and one more befitting the cultural significance of a new state, would be this: "Plough and Palm of Peace!"
The Week.
Vienna, 22 July.
The essay which we place to-day at the head of our paper signifies a gratifying advance of Zionism. Its author, Baron Suttner, is the president of the Society for the Defence against Anti-Semitism. As such he was soundly assailed by the Jew-baiters, and had also his full measure of molestation on account of his "friendship for the Jews."
Baron Suttner has been in a position to gather all manner of experience; and one will in any case be entitled to reckon him among the people who understand something of the Jewish question. When such a man comes forward after years of fruitless attempts and