Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 7 · 16 July 1897
4printed page
scan 8 of 20

Page 4. — "Die Welt" — No. 7.


(continued from page 3)

… the more grateful to him for it if he were not erroneously taken for a defender of the Jews. We need not inquire who is to blame for this misunderstanding: he himself or others; perhaps merely his too subtle attitude. In such conflicts of opinion as the Jewish question occasions, the contradictio in adjecto is incomprehensible and therefore intolerable. One cannot be an anti-Semite who does the Jews justice, one cannot be a Guelph Ghibelline.

In the third part, which treats the economic side of the question, Leroy-Beaulieu explains how the Jews were thrown by historical circumstances upon trade and upon the money business; how the once agricultural and warlike people was drained of its strength; how it nevertheless did not lose its appetite for bodily labour, the proof being the mass conditions in the East of Europe and the frightful Sweating in England and America, where the Jews are reproached not with parasitism in the middleman's trade, but with the degradation of the Standard of life of the workers. All this we know very exactly, but he said it to the anti-Semites. With them, to be sure, it goes in at one ear and out at the other. They complain of a condition; it is all one to them how it is to be explained historically. In its politico-economical essence anti-Semitism is a protectionist movement. Was this not seen quite lately even in "Jew-friendly" Hungary, in the remarkable and far too little noticed closing of the frontier against the Russian immigration? Mr. Leroy-Beaulieu understands so much, he understands so finely; only his own time he does not understand. He still believes rigidly in the laissez faire, laissez aller. That is over and done with. Whether one lament it or rejoice over it, it is over and done with. One will come back to it again some day, but at present the world stands under another sign. Mr. Leroy-Beaulieu does not love the Jews, and yet he combats anti-Semitism; here at last we come to the explanation of this contradiction. He is a Liberal, rigidly doctrinaire, of the old school, the Left Centre.

His principles are dearer to him than his antipathy. The anti-Semites are of a more consistent mind, perhaps because they order their principles according to their antipathy.

And Mr. Leroy-Beaulieu draws his conclusions from his premises. He is for liberty, equal right for all; first, because that is his principle; secondly, because in the Jewish question there is no other way out. What solutions do the anti-Semites propose? Exceptional laws or the expulsion of the Jews. Neither does Leroy-Beaulieu hold to be commendable. The exceptional laws, which he had occasion to study in Russia, did not prove themselves. Moreover, what is possible in an autocracy would be hard to transplant into a democracy. Against expulsion, however, there speaks in his view above all this, that the expulsion of the Jews might later be followed by the expulsion of others, and finally of the Jesuits. To this is added the difficulty that in other countries too men would like to expel the Jews. Whither should they all go? "The problem seems to me insoluble," he writes, and immediately adds:

"There is, to be sure, still one procedure, which my loyalty forbids me to pass over in silence. That would be the re-establishment of the Jewish State." And he speaks briefly of our Zionist movement. Yet he does not believe that the erection of the Jewish State would be the fitting solution. This does not surprise us further, after his premises, and in particular not after the weakness of his remarks upon the national side of the Jewish question. He thinks also that the land of our fathers would no longer have room enough for us. Let him leave that to be our care. To begin with, not all Jews would go thither. Those who are well off would remain where they are, until their fortunes crumble and they and their families are absorbed in their present surroundings. It would not even be in the interest of the anti-Semitic countries to lose all their Jews. A healthy outflow would begin and would last as long as anti-Semitism lasts. On the day, in the minute, when the mood of a country turns in favour of the Jews, not one will stir from the spot, and certainly no well-situated man. Zionism puts into the hands of the nations the means of regulating the number of their Jews according to their need. That, that is the solution of the Jewish question.

And what should become of the present inhabitants of Palestine, of Mussulmans and Christians? inquires Mr. Leroy-Beaulieu. What? In our view they would be the best off of all, because they would receive labour, traffic and culture in their poor, barren land. And what should become of the holy places? We believe that these will never again pass into the possession of any power whatever. In international law they are surely for ever extra commercium. What belongs to all can and will belong to none. Who is able to imagine that the various Christian confessions would give over the possession of the holy places to a single one of them? The growing differentiation of the Christian confessions has indeed led so far that men have found reassurance in knowing the holy places to be in the keeping of non-Christians. And granted, though not conceded, that it should ever come to that, it is more than questionable whether the res sacrae of the civilised world would be handed over precisely to officially irreligious France.

For that, in fact, is Mr. Leroy-Beaulieu's idea, as he confesses, forgetting the publicity of the printed book, "since we are here among ourselves Frenchmen." He would like — partant pour la Syrie — to have the land of the Jews for France after the partition of Turkey. Well, the partition of Turkey has still a good way to go. Since Mr. Leroy-Beaulieu delivered his lecture, Turkey has given quite sound proofs of her vitality. Of the partition of Turkey no serious politician thinks any longer at present. To be sure, Turkey needs financial help more urgently than ever, and this she will be able to obtain only through the Jews. It is not a question of taking a province from the Sultan, but only of creating a homestead secured by international law for those Jews who cannot exist elsewhere.

We have said this often already, and we shall go on saying it untiringly until we are understood. We Zionists go further on our way, unbowed, undaunted, under mockery and hostility, over intrigues and basenesses, until we are understood. But if shopkeepers, self-seekers and low people misunderstand us, the lovers of beautiful and great ideas ought to bestow their sympathies upon us. It is surely no small thing: the renaissance of an unhappy, lost people. A Leroy-Beaulieu of the future will perhaps describe our movement — whether it shall have conquered or been overcome — with good will.

For the Leroy-Beaulieu of to-day, however — he will read these lines — we will set down here the fragrance and the music of Béranger's verses, which perhaps he no longer recalls. He will enjoy them thoughtfully. *)

Combien de temps une pensée, Vierge obscure attend son époux! Les sots la traitent d'insensée, Le sage lui dit: Cachez-vous. Mais la rencontrant loin du monde, Un fou, qui croit au lendemain, L'épouse: elle devient féconde Pour le bonheur du genre humain.

✡

*) Literal translation: How long does an idea wait, An obscure virgin, for her suitor! The dull call her mad, The wise man says to her: hide thyself! Then, far from all men, she meets A fool who still believes in the morrow, And he weds her; and as she becomes fruitful, It is the happiness of all mankind.


To our Readers!

Upon the conclusion of the tale "Uriel Acosta" by I. Zangwill we shall bring the excellent novella

Chawa Rubin

by I. Okonsti.

The Editors.