Die Welt.
No. 7. — Vol. I. — Appears every Friday. — Vienna, 16 July 1897.
Editorial Office and Administration: Vienna II., Rembrandtstrasse 11. — Advertising rates: the four-column nonpareil line, 10 kr.
Subscription rates. For Austria-Hungary: half-yearly 3 fl. = 6 Kr., yearly 6 fl. = 12 Kr. For abroad: half-yearly 4 fl. = 8 Kr., yearly 8 fl. = 16 Kr. Single numbers 15 kr.
Communications are to be addressed not to individual persons but to the Editorial Office or the Administration, Vienna, II., Rembrandtstrasse 11. Unstamped letters will not be accepted, and manuscripts will not be returned.
Protest-Rabbis.
The newest thing in the Jewish movement is the protest-rabbis. Max Nordau has already branded this type with a word that will endure: they are the people who sit in the safe boat and strike with the oar upon the heads of the drowning who would fain cling to the gunwale. Such, already, is the ordinary aggressive Jewish enemy of Zion. Add to him an appointment as "pastor of souls" to a larger congregation, and the protest-rabbi is complete. Five such protest-rabbis have issued the following declaration in the "Berliner Tageblatt" and elsewhere:
The managing board of the Rabbinical Association in Germany: Dr. Maybaum (Berlin), Dr. Horovitz (Frankfort), Dr. Guttmann (Breslau), Dr. Auerbach (Halberstadt), Dr. Werner (Munich) publishes the following declaration: "Through the convocation of a Zionist Congress and through the publication of its programme, such erroneous notions concerning the doctrinal content of Judaism and concerning the aspirations of its adherents have been spread abroad that the undersigned board of the Rabbinical Association in Germany deems it incumbent upon it to issue the following declaration:
-
The endeavours of the so-called Zionists to found a Jewish national state in Palestine contradict the messianic promises of Judaism as they are contained in Holy Scripture and in the later sources of religion.
-
Judaism obliges its adherents to serve with all devotion the fatherland to which they belong, and to further its national interests with their whole heart and with all their powers.
-
With this obligation, however, there stands in no contradiction those noble endeavours which aim at the colonisation of Palestine by Jewish husbandmen, since they have no relation whatever to the founding of a national state.
Religion and love of the fatherland therefore lay upon us in equal measure the duty of entreating all to whom the welfare of Judaism is dear to hold themselves aloof from the aforementioned Zionist endeavours, and most especially from the Congress still projected in spite of every dissuasion."
This is a remarkable document. The first impression we have of it is that it will not exactly heighten the standing of the Jews. The whole declaration is, as every Jew sees at the first glance, turned outward. It is one of those contemptible and despised protestations that whine for the favour of enemies.
Fortunately not all rabbis are so. Names such as those of Mohilewer in Bialystok, Zadok Kahn in Paris, Rülf in Memel, Gaster in London, and many, many others we can name only with sincere reverence. And we do so not as men of party. Zionism is not a party. One may come to it from all parties, even as it embraces all the parties of a people's life. Zionism is the Jewish people on its way. And for that reason the conduct of the protest-rabbis is monstrous.
If any man will turn away from the Jewish nation from which he springs and go over to another people, let him only do so. We Zionists shall not detain him. Only he is a stranger to us. His new national concerns are of no nearer interest to us, nor ours to him. He has nothing to say in our affairs, and if he is prudent he will not so much as attempt it, for among Teutons, Gauls, Anglo-Saxons it can only render him suspect if he still troubles himself about internal Jewish matters. If he would win companions for his assimilatory solution of the Jewish question, the best means thereto is that he should show how well he is received, how fully he is acknowledged, how comfortable he finds himself.
But to belong to Judaism, to practise Judaism professionally, so to speak, and at the same time to combat it — that is something against which every sense of right must rebel.
Let us now look point by point at the "declaration" of the five gentlemen. It rests upon a fundamental untruth. The five gentlemen state that "through the convocation of a Zionist Congress and through the publication of its programme such erroneous notions concerning the doctrinal content of Judaism and concerning the aspirations of its adherents have been spread abroad." Where have the five gentlemen read in the "convocation" or in the "programme" of the Congress any reference whatever to the "doctrinal content of Judaism"? Of that there stands not a word, not even the remotest hint, in the announcements of the conveners. Consequently something other than the convocation of the Congress may also be to blame for the "so erroneous notions concerning the doctrinal content" which these five gentlemen profess to know. The five gentlemen must, moreover, have laughed right heartily when they took the "so erroneous notions concerning the doctrinal content," etc., for a pretext. And now they pass on to point 1. "The endeavours of so-called Zionists, etc." "So-called" is good; "so-called" is even very good. There is irony in it. Later commentators will call point 1 of the declaration the ironical one. What sort of face may the five gentlemen have made when they took the "messianic promises of Judaism" into their mouths? We know well enough by now how they turn and construe everything into its opposite. When they speak of Zion, everything is to be understood thereby — only, for God's sake, not Zion.
A thorough refutation of this first point has been placed at our disposal by a man as truly pious as he is learned. Precisely out of Holy Scripture