Die Welt.
No. 6. Vol. I.
Editorial Office and Administration: Vienna II., Rembrandtstrasse 11.
Advertising rates: The four-column petit line, 10 kr.
Published every Friday.
Vienna, 9 July 1897.
Communications are to be addressed not to individual persons, but to the Editorial Office or the Administration, Vienna, II., Rembrandtstrasse 11.
Unstamped letters will not be accepted, and manuscripts will not be returned.
Subscription rates. For Austria-Hungary: Half-yearly 3 fl. = 6 Kr. Yearly 6 fl. = 12 Kr. For abroad: Half-yearly 4 fl. = 8 Kr. Yearly 8 fl. = 16 Kr. Single numbers 15 kr.
Leroy-Beaulieu on Antisemitism.
Monsieur Anatole Leroy-Beaulieu, who already owes to the Jews one of his best books, Israël chez les nations, has lately occupied himself with us again. This time the elegant writer has been less happy than in his first Israelite work. In his little book l'Antisémitisme he gives the impression of having no great deal to say upon the Jewish question. And whereas one could read the 433 pages of Israel among the Nations with unbroken sympathy and take pleasure in the author's lightly discursive learning, in this short lecture of 75 small pages one soon feels a certain emptiness.
L'Antisémitisme was in fact an extempore lecture, a so-called "conférence," which M. Leroy-Beaulieu delivered some months ago at the Institut catholique in Paris. This setting, the person of the speaker, and the nature of the interruptions to which he was exposed ought properly to have moved the great newspapers to concern themselves more closely with the affair. But it is well known that people do not care to speak of the Jewish question; they still believe it can be killed by silence. There is something uncanny in such blindness on the part of otherwise clever people. It is as though a man, in a place where smoking is forbidden, were to thrust his burning tobacco-pipe into his pocket. He burns a hole in his coat and is caught in the end all the same.
Among the hushed-up events in the modern development of the Jewish question belongs also Leroy-Beaulieu's lecture at the Catholic Institute. It was a remarkable occurrence, and it ended in general dissatisfaction. The antisemites, against whom M. Leroy-Beaulieu let fly from a Catholic rostrum, had a bad day of it. But M. Leroy-Beaulieu had no good one either. And worst off of all were the Jews, for they were defended by M. Leroy-Beaulieu. Such a defender is the heaviest misfortune that can befall an accused man. M. Leroy-Beaulieu speaks of the Jews with a positively annihilating benevolence; he shames them by his kindness, and never have they so much cause to be contrite as when he excuses them. A Jew of sound and not immodest self-respect must feel himself quite crumpled up and thrown away after he has read to the end the writing of this obliging academician. Whence may this come? We are truly not spoiled. Day after day we hear debated the apparently difficult question whether we too are human beings like others. There are people who answer this question decidedly in the negative; then those who affirm it with reservations; few are for us without qualification, and that is humanly explicable. "Love thy neighbour" is nothing everyday — would it otherwise have made such a stir in the history of the world? . . . In short, we are not spoiled. We have even unlearned the habit of lamenting our lot. We bear it as it comes. And now one comes and lays hold of us with a soft, smooth hand, as though to do us good; but we feel nothing therein save pain. Is our morbid oversensitiveness to blame for it? No, the good man is stroking our open wounds. Let him burn them, cut them, let him deal us new ones, if he is a proper enemy; but what is the use of stroking, since he is no proper friend?
Therein lies the matter. Upon the Jewish question one can write to-day only as an avowed partisan. That is to say: the Jewish question has two aspects, an historical and an actual one. The historical may be contemplated with cool composure; indeed, academic serenity is there very meritorious. But the actual Jewish question does not bear this cool manner of treatment. On this side and on that men suffer and struggle; on this side there is more suffering, on that more strife. But if one comes who would contemplate this spectacle with untroubled equanimity — one might say, enjoy it — he will rouse anger in both camps. Whoever would now take part in the Jewish question must first declare whether he is Guelph or Ghibelline. In this posture of affairs there can as yet be no historians, at most war correspondents, and let these be cautious, or they will be dealt with under martial law.
It was therefore imprudent of M. Leroy-Beaulieu to go on the 27th of February 1897 into the Catholic Institute, in order to explain mildly to the antisemites in what respects he could not entirely agree with them, and to the Jews, who listened from afar, what infirmities he had to censure in them. For the wise qualifications, reservations and restrictions in this address nobody has any feeling. One would not believe how much vexation so gentle an exposition is able to excite. M. Leroy-Beaulieu's lecture is a fine example of how madly circumspection can turn out. And yet he stands as before upon the standpoint of his book Israel among the Nations; he says not a word whose efficacy he had not already tried; the clever man has only forgotten that book and speech, history and politics, are two different things. A philosopher must be able to keep silence, a politician to speak.
Afterwards, following his "conférence," M. Leroy-Beaulieu perceived this; the proof of it is the preface to the little book. There he publishes his reply to the "General Delegate of the Antisemitic League of France." The letter is pungent. M. Leroy-Beaulieu has lost the equanimity we admired in him so long as it was the Jews who were attacked. This refined scholar has temperament too. He writes to the General Delegate: "Sir! You have in an open letter