Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 5 · 2 July 1897
5printed page
scan 9 of 20

No. 5. — "Die Welt" — Page 5.

Hurrah-Nationalism.

By Dr. N. Birnbaum.

Zionism has from the first met with all manner of misunderstandings. It is by now somewhat better off, to be sure, yet it still ranks among the worst-misjudged movements. This would give us little cause for concern if we had to do only with those conceited and miseducated circles which fancy themselves entitled to instruct us in the elements of history. But the evil reaches far beyond these bearers of an implacable mediocrity; we find it among the leading intellects. And that is a serious matter. For how far are we to come if we have these against us? They and the people are as the hand and the clock! As the going of the works acquires meaning only through the hand, so the instinctive life of a people acquires significance only through its leaders. How, then, are we to win the people, if its intellectual kings are sulking?

Nevertheless the circumstance that so many eminent men still stand in antipathy to our endeavours need not dismay us. Even for great intellects there are fields that lie remote from them. If a new question arises upon such a field, one on which they are called to take a position, they do not deal with it with their accustomed soundness and originality. They then either rely upon the account given by others, or, upon the strength of catchwords and names picked up at random, with which they are accustomed to associate a definite and otherwise justified judgment, they form opinions which in this one case, strange to them, are precisely prejudices.

Thus the principal cause of the dismissive or hostile attitude of many mighty intellects towards Zionism may well lie in the aversion which the very names of the movement awaken in them.

In the first place the thing is already suspect to them as Jewish. Judaism repels most of them, although — or because — they have by no means yet overcome it in their intellectual and bodily type. It lies as a burden of the past upon their backs, and they do not wish to see it shifted before their eyes, which are turned toward the future. And then this name "Zionism," which reminds them of the pulpit eloquence of Christian clergymen, of the Klopstockian muse, of "watchmen of Zion" — in short, of nothing but things which, in minds turned toward the modern, unromantic bustle of the world, arouse only feelings of distaste!

For all that, however, this name is likely to do comparatively little mischief. For in any case, through the union of the modern ending with the immemorial word "Zion," it sounds interesting enough to stir curiosity. Most will therefore inquire further, though in expectation of uncanny things. But there they will come upon a word which heightens their repugnance still further and is well fitted to set the seal upon their prejudice. They hear that Zionism is a national movement.

For national movements have fallen into grave discredit — and that not merely among the dogmatists of cosmopolitanism, who are quite as flat as the phrase-mongers of nationalism, but also among mature and rich natures. These feel a kind of aesthetic disgust at the shallow bustle of nationalism as it commonly presents itself, against Hurrah-Nationalism.

I have formed this word upon the model of the familiar "Hurrah-Patriotism," and in so doing I have done that notion an injustice. For Hurrah-Nationalism is not so repulsive as Hurrah-Patriotism — witness the utterly pitiable protestations of the official Jewish circles in the face of the announcement of the Munich Congress, protestations that must provoke the indignation of every nobler patriot! In it there riot, not baseness of sentiment as in the other, but merely narrowness of mind. The hurrah-patriot is a cool speculator; the hurrah-nationalist is a drunken man who cannot be held responsible, because he has no purposes. And with this we have laid bare the essence of Hurrah-Nationalism. It is purposelessness, the want of content.

Purpose and content are, of course, not the same thing. A thing may be very full of content and yet have no purpose. It even appears that the purposeless contents are the richest, the most abounding, are life itself. But political movements — the word "political" taken in its widest sense — are never purposeless life itself. They are rather direct purposes, by which we — leaving aside the driving powers above us — intervene in life, in order to shape its automatic unrolling as we should wish it to be. And therefore, while some feeling of pleasure or displeasure without a purpose may be a matter of course and not otherwise conceivable at all, a political movement without a purpose is an absurdity.

Now nationality in itself is not a political movement at all. It is purposeless content, like all the rest of life. That a man is a Jew belongs to his very being; he is one whether he will or no. Nationality becomes nationalism only when it is in some way hindered, or acts as a hindrance, and thereby renders political purposes necessary. If a national movement is got up without this necessity, we have before us a barren piece of play, having no more sense than it would have to create a social movement when economic conditions leave nothing to be desired.

Such Hurrah-Nationalism is commonly to be explained thus: that the temper of certain classes of a people, which will hear nothing of the social question, is unoccupied, and in its perplexity throws itself upon the nationalism which shines out to it from bygone days of struggle, but which is by now already outlived. It is a mark of national movements so arisen that they are at bottom un-national, that is, that in their imagined necessity of movement they forget the normal national functions. Never do the language, the science and the art of a people fall more into neglect and grow more outward than when it stands under the sign of chauvinism. Thus, for example, Prusso-German nationalism injures the true German spirit, flattens it and hollows it out.

Of course there are also intermediate stages between the two extremes of a thoroughly justified and a thoroughly unjustified national movement. Such are to be found, for instance, among most of the Austrian and Hungarian peoples. Yet even here a strong chauvinistic, purposelessly national element presses to the front, an element well fitted to repel distinguished and leading intellects. This is wholly wanting in Zionism. Individual Zionists may perhaps bear themselves as the hurrah-nationalists of other peoples do — a thing explained by the bad example — but the Zionist movement as such is entirely free of such trumpery, freer perhaps even than the kindred movements of the Irish, the Poles and the Armenians. The Zionist movement is throughout a movement of purpose, as accords also with the Jewish character, which is rather too much than too little given to purpose. From this point of view Zionism presents itself as the successor of Assimilation, which was likewise a pure movement of purpose. Like the latter, it too would solve the Jewish question, that is, would make possible for the Jew once more the purposeless enjoyment of life. Only the means has become another: the Jewish State, the people's own home.

How greatly the Zionist movement is distinguished, by this earnest purpose of its own, which must be taken in earnest, from the national playthings of other peoples, is shown particularly also by the peculiar character of Zionist party life as against the nature of the hurrah-nationalist parties. On the one side a programmatic exclusion of socialist views, an alarming poverty of social substance, a ridiculous affectation and craziness. On the other side, among the Zionists, a free hand in matters of philosophy, a strong social atmosphere, a clear and sane enthusiasm.

Nevertheless Zionism is again and again thrown into one pot with movements of lesser worth. The leading intellects do it in good faith. But those