No. 4. — "Die Welt" — Page 7.
(continued from page 6)
… is, that Zionism shall become, out of a plaything in the hands of chance and of a few money-givers, a serious concern of the community at large; out of a "practical" and romantic movement, a real one; out of a reactionary house of correction for convictions, a wide open field of battle; out of the whim of a portion of the Jewish educated philistines, the will of the people."
We believe that the author does the "Practicals" an injustice when he supposes of them that they will come to the Congress and there oppose it with arguments to the point. These gentlemen prefer to stay at home and content themselves with working up feeling against the Congress by intrigues and coloured reports. In any case his article will do much to shed light upon the Berlin conditions.
Christians on the Jewish Question.
Baron Suttner, President of the Society for the Defence against Anti-Semitism.
Much esteemed Editors!
The column "The Week" in Number 2 of "Die Welt" contains a discussion of the general meeting of the Defence Society, and as President of this Society let it be permitted me to say a few words in reply:
The title "Society for the Defence against Anti-Semitism" has unfortunately from the very outset given rise to regrettable misunderstandings, in that the word "defence" was construed to mean that the Society was intended to come forward as a militant and protective association on behalf of Jewry. By this interpretation our purposes have been wholly and entirely misapprehended.
The founding of the Society rested first of all upon the idea of gathering all right-thinking fellow-citizens into a public protest against a movement which in every one of its articles has declared war upon the fundamental laws of the State. Not, as our opponents said, a bodyguard for the Jews were we to be, but an association of men who take a stand against every assault upon human right. Had the agitation been directed against the Protestants or Mohammedans living in Austria, we should probably have banded together in just the same way to protest against so crying an injustice. I think, then, that in this demonstration there was nothing, and is nothing, shameful or wounding to be sought for the Jews.
The want of backbone which Hofrath Nothnagel in his address rightly deplored was indeed the reason that we remained isolated, and I concur entirely in your reproach that this want makes itself felt not only among the Christian but also among the Jewish inhabitants of Austria. We might have made of our Society of Protest a Society of Combat, had those whose good right we represented joined themselves to us more actively. I believe I do not go astray in assuming that there live in Austria-Hungary two millions of Jews. Had but five per cent. of these thrown in their lot with us, we should have become a power; we might have passed over from the ideal into the real, we might have entered the electoral struggle with ethical and with the indispensable material means, we might have sent out popular speakers and canvassers — in short, we should have been in a position to lay obstacles betimes in the path of our adversary which he perhaps would not have surmounted.
That this was not achieved is the fault neither of the Society nor of its tendency. We were left, to use a popular expression, sitting in the mire; by Jews and by Christians alike. Had the Liberal party at that time, while it was still a power, taken up a position against the yet more flagrant maltreatment of our Jewish fellow-citizens with the same fury it now displays in the matter of the Language Ordinance; had the Government moreover done its duty after the example of Hungary; then Liberalism would not have been shattered, and we should stand to-day otherwise than is unhappily the case. But men had deaf ears for us, and in their higher wisdom held that the affair would run itself out in the sand.
We know very well that one cannot break a storm-flood with a pebble — and a pebble is what our Society at present is against that anti-Semitic storm-flood. Neither do we wish to be modern Don Quixotes; but we do wish, for all that, to preserve our right as free men, the right to cry forth our protest against a movement which offends in the deepest degree our ethical feelings as men and as Austrian citizens. And because we will not surrender this our right, therefore we hold out at our post, therefore we do not haul in our flag, therefore the Defence Society continues to exist so long as our strength shall last.
Respectfully Suttner. Harmannsdorf, June 1897.
The Colonisation of Argentina.
For publication we have received from Herr F. S. Trachtmann in Ackermann, the plenipotentiary in matters concerning the Jewish emigration to Argentina, the following letter, which the colonists settled in the district of "Entre-Rios" in Argentina have addressed to Baroness Hirsch, Rabbi Adler, Goldsmid, Montefiore and other members of the "Jewish Colon. Association":
"When Baron Hirsch caused his intention to be proclaimed in Russia of settling the Jews of that country in Argentina and of giving them landed property there, that they might devote themselves to agriculture, we were full of joy at tidings so rich in promise for our people and its future. With enthusiasm we received these tidings, and rejoiced to be, as it were, the pioneers called to free Israel from the reproach of shirking labour. Courageously and resolutely we took upon ourselves this honourable and sacred duty; for three years we have tilled our soil in the sweat of our brow, restlessly and untiringly, as is testified with commendation both by our neighbours and by travellers who have visited the colonies. Yet all our toilsome labour has hitherto, alas, been without any success whatever.
"In the first year of our settlement we turned to garden culture, since it was too late for field work. We laid out splendid gardens and planted them with everything needful for our households. Immeasurably great was our joy; when the crop gave promise of thriving gloriously, our gardens were suddenly covered by the 'Biche more' known in these parts, and these little insects destroyed everything utterly.
"In the second year we went into the fields, worked there with all our might, the grain began to thrive most beautifully, and the sight of it made the future of the colonies appear to us in a brilliant light. Then, towards the end of September, we were suddenly visited by locusts, which destroyed our crop for the greater part. During the harvest violent downpours of rain did great damage, and the 'Biche more' too did their share to lay waste all that the locusts had spared, and so once more we came away empty-handed. The Administration now met us with consideration for our situation and granted each man a support of 150 pesos; but that did not help much.
"In the third year we went to work with joyful hope, in spite of the misfortunes we had suffered, and almost all the colonists sowed their fields. This time too the prospect of a blessed harvest seemed all but assured; then, last July, the heaven was covered as with a gloomy cloud; a dense swarm of locusts came down, more terrible than we had ever yet beheld, and our whole labour was totally destroyed, so that not a trace of it remained.
"Some tried once again to sow, after receiving seed from the Administration; again the sowing throve, but the locusts returned once more and over-
