Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 2 · 11 June 1897
6printed page
scan 10 of 20

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 2.

For we find ourselves in an essentially different situation from the Jews of the East. These stand outside modern European culture and are entitled, by the very completeness of their opposition to it, to speak of their own cultural world as a Jewish one. We, however, take part in modern European culture, which is filled with a distinctive national life only for those peoples who are willing and strong enough to permeate it therewith. If, then, Jewish life is to pulse among us, we must either voluntarily place ourselves upon the cultural standpoint of our eastern brethren, or we must have the will and the strength to found a national, a Jewish life in spite of and within European culture. The first aim, which may indeed hold a particular allurement for many romantically disposed natures, is happily a sheer impossibility; the second is Zionism.

What existed of Jewish "life" in Germany before Zionism, however, by no means entitles anyone to set the Jews of Germany above those of Austria. It is doubtless a fact that more money is given for Jewish learning in Germany than in Austria; but it is also a fact that this learning is not that of a living but of a departed Judaism, and is moreover pursued in great part by Germanized Hungarian or Polish Jews. It is correct that more Jewish papers appear in Germany than in Austria; but it is also correct that their circle of readers at home is no very large one, and that their journalistic value is for the most part a very low one. It is true that there is in Germany a far more cultivated orthodoxy than in Austria; but it is also true that it has not the smell of the soil, the primitive originality, which it has here, where orthodoxy still hangs together in some measure with the East. It must be conceded that of non-orthodox and highly cultivated persons who take an interest in Jewish matters there are perhaps a few more than in Austria; but it must equally be conceded that the de-Judaizing of those leading spirits so important to a people has advanced much, much further in Germany than in Austria. It is an advantage of Germany that Jewish societies for history and literature exist here on every hand; but how slight their significance is shall yet be set forth, and they would not exist at all had there not been a few Zionists to call them into being.

The Zionists of Germany differ essentially from those of Austria. Their method is another. This lies in part in the fact that it has developed under a lesser pressure of anti-Semitism. Yet that cannot be the sole ground, for the English Zionists, for example, owe nothing whatever to anti-Semitism, and nevertheless approach in their type the Austrian rather than the German comrades in conviction. The difference of method must therefore be traceable to still other grounds as well: to the contrast of temperament between the North-German and the Austrian-influenced Jew, but for the very greatest part perhaps to the accidental circumstance that precisely certain personalities, of a peculiar cast conditioning the German method, were the first to come forward as Zionists in Germany.

There are not many Zionists in Germany. Of a popular movement such as is now beginning in Austria, not a trace! Not even a student movement. If one wished to inscribe the beads of a counting-frame with all the names of the conscious Zionists of Germany, a good many beads would probably be left uninscribed. Yet one would have to lie were one unwilling to admit that this group accomplishes great things by the method it has chosen. It renounces "movement" from the outset; it altogether overlooks and underrates the dangers of a colonization into the blue; it has no notion of the might and weight of public opinion — but at its own work, the gradual infiltration of Palestine with Jews, it labours with restless zeal. Just now it can look back upon a series of great successes. There is first of all the collecting society "Esra," which in the past year numbered well over 2000 members in more than 200 towns, took in close upon 7000 marks, and expended about 19,000 marks for Palestinian purposes. A further advance is the Palestine Exhibition at last year's Berlin Trade Exhibition, which afterwards pitched its tents in Cologne and Breslau as well, and shortly intends to pitch them in Frankfort-on-Main also. The products there brought to view, and above all the wines exhibited, were indisputably able to contribute much toward winning a good repute for Palestinian soil and its husbandmen. A similar undertaking will be the participation of the colonies in this year's Hamburg Garden Exhibition. Beside these passing undertakings — which, moreover, disclose to us the essential use of practical colonization, its propagandist value — the Zionists of Germany provide for permanent enterprises in support of colonization. Thus some months ago a "Palestine Import Company" was formed, which maintains a fashionable sales establishment in the City of Berlin; and from Berlin likewise proceeds the project, now near to its realization, of founding in Paris, with the money of Jewish capitalists of all lands, an agrarian bank for Palestine.

Characteristically, this bank will not describe itself as Jewish, and will name Syria in its statutes as its field of operation. Mystery-making with open secrets — that is precisely a trait of character of the German Zionist movement, following logically from mere infiltration. For love of this mystery-making the absolutely requisite great political measures are left untaken.

Now the German Zionists have, to be sure, other endeavours besides those directed merely to infiltration. Driven first, no doubt, by their strong Jewish feeling, and then also considering that one must provide for ever new donors, they exert themselves likewise to awaken in the Jewish population of the German Empire a sense for Jewish matters and to create Jewish rallying-points. First of all they naturally need such for themselves, that is, for the innermost Zionist circles. Two societies serve this purpose: "Jung-Israel" in Berlin and the "Nationaljüdische Vereinigung" in Cologne. The former is already several years old, and has significance exclusively as a place of instruction and encouragement for the most purposeful comrades in Berlin. The latter has further-reaching intentions — it aims at an organization of the German Zionists — but as it has only just been born, one cannot of course say how far it will get. A third, strictly Zionist forum, the journal "Zion" — which appears in three languages (German, French, Hebrew) — has, precisely as a paper, and in so far as it does not voluntarily restrict itself by a manner of writing calculated for more exquisite circles, perhaps the widest effect of all. In it, moreover, all shades of Zionist opinion come to expression.

Among the endeavours to create rallying-places for Jews in general, the founding, brought about several years ago by Zionists, of the Union of Societies for Jewish History and Literature is especially to be signalized. Well, what is done there is altogether laudable. It can do no harm to the people who come to hear lectures upon Jewish themes; but that they should thereby be rendered fitter for Zionism is at the least questionable. For these lectures are popular without being of the people. That says everything. The people go away no more Jewish than they came. At most they carry off with them a little piety — that nasty, soporific surrogate for feelings really great and begetting of deeds. And that is a damage to Zionism. For the Zionists themselves let themselves be seduced by such lumber — which is as repugnant to an old, genuine, dyed-in-the-wool Jew of the East as to a thoroughly modern man — into backward-looking romantic inclinations. Then they go and attempt to make competition for orthodoxy — without any tenable ground whatever. For orthodoxy can subsist in Germany without foreign aid, and neither strict belief nor free views in matters of religion have hitherto hindered anyone from becoming and remaining a Zionist, if only he had a sense for it. Every taking of sides in these things is the highest maladroitness. Zionism is solely a national and social movement.