Page 14. — "Die Welt" — No. 1.
(continued from page 13)
…material, have tried to interpret the riddles and to resolve the contradictions; but the attempt has succeeded with them only in small measure.
A writer of Jewish descent and of brilliant parts has devoted his great powers to the same problem, and has sought in Disraeli's literary works the key that could not be forged out of the biographical data alone. Georg Brandes, with his keenly penetrating critical knife, has laid bare many a fold in Disraeli's heart; the Jewish origin of the statesman and poet has explained to him many a feature in the intellectual countenance of his hero. Yet precisely before those works of Disraeli's in which that paternal inheritance asserts itself most plainly, he stands even more at a loss and without understanding than the Christian biographers do: Georg Brandes passes over Alroy, Coningsby, Tancred with an assumed air of superiority. The Jew of humanity, Brandes, has evidently approached the national idea of the Jew of race, Disraeli, only with great uneasiness, and it was very welcome and very convenient to him to toss the "unscientific theology" — as though there had ever been, or ever could be, a scientific theology — with a wave of the hand among the novelist's other singularities, and to proclaim the man himself the last Jew.
In the year 1879, the year in which Brandes gave his essay on Disraeli to the public, it did indeed look as though Disraeli, the new Christian, had been the last Jew. But time has not confirmed this hypothesis; on the contrary, Disraeli was the first Jew in the sense of the new generation, and now it is perhaps time that a Jew who has undertaken to know himself as such, and who holds it the finest and the wisest thing to make himself known as such to others also, should seek in his own way to understand the remarkable man who appeared so enigmatic and so full of contradiction both to the Christians and to a Jew of humanity.
Certainly Benjamin Disraeli was a very rich, many-sided nature, burdened from the outset with sundry incompatibilities — a nature which in any country, in any society, under any education, in all circumstances would have made upon poorer and therefore simpler people the impression of something inharmonious and unbalanced. A strong individuality from first to last, he yet more than once, and in more than one field, followed the reigning current that was inwardly foreign to him as slavishly as any thoughtless hero of fashion: he was a dandy at the moment when a new cut of waistcoat was engaging the attention of the highest personages in London society; a freethinker of the purest water by inheritance, by education, by his own study and by the tendency of the age, he plays on important occasions the protector of the Church and of ecclesiastical authority; a despiser of money and of the power of money in modern England, he married a woman ten years his senior, avowedly for the sake of her wealth. All this, and much else besides, Disraeli would doubtless have done as a born Christian or a Mussulman, as a full-blooded Englishman or Frenchman. Ambition was the ruling passion of his life; power was to him a necessity like meat and drink; to ambition and to power the subordinate wishes and needs were sacrificed. But beside this great passion of his life — of which he was perfectly conscious from the beginning, and to which from his earliest youth he willingly and without any moral scruple surrendered the helm, with a clearness and a firmness proper to the great man — there worked in the depths of his soul a second force: his membership in the Jewish stock, outwardly lost through baptism, yet inwardly held fast as a thing not to be surrendered. Had Disraeli, with his great ambition, his need of power and his gifts, which made him a born leader of men, come into the world as the scion of a house long settled in England, he could hardly have become more to his fatherland than he became to England; but all the rents and fissures in his political character, the by-paths and shifts in his dealings with the parties, the involuntary changes and concessions in the heavy struggle of decades against the aversion and mistrust of the great masses, would have been spared the statesman: Disraeli would have become the Bismarck of the English.
Had Disraeli not been estranged from Judaism as a boy of thirteen by a worldly-minded and short-sighted father, had he remained a Jew among Jews, then the world would have beheld with its own eyes as event that which Disraeli's imagination cast upon paper as poetry; the man who won Egypt and Cyprus for England, and who knew how to give the centrifugal parts of the British world-empire an attractive centre, a heart and a soul, by his revival of the monarchical idea — this man would have been able to give his people also a new and undisputed home.
But Disraeli was once for all baptized; already as a child he had lived exclusively among Christians — among very lukewarm professors of Christianity, it is true, such as Samuel Rogers — and he entered upon his political career furnished with every civil right. Why, then, did he not let the past rest, a past which was not even his own past, nay, not even that of his father and grandfather, for these two had been Epicureans in the Talmudic and in the ordinary sense alike; why did he not forget his descent, once his father had made good the defect of his birth?
Ah, if only that could be done! One does not forget one's Jewish descent; the will to forget signifies little here. It is a mysterious but undeniable law: whoever has once belonged to Judaism never again stands toward it as a stranger, cold and indifferent. Hatred or love, according to temperament and circumstance a glowing hatred or a glowing love — one of the two; the indifference of a Jew toward Judaism is, consciously or unconsciously, a lie.
Heavily burdened, Disraeli began his political activity. Three forces tugged at him and drew him in three different directions. Ambition urged him toward a position of power at any price; the inherited feeling of the stock raised its voice, now loudly, now softly, but always insistently; and the Christian confession drew him back again and again to the Church with irresistible force. Where is the reader of souls who can construct the resultant of these three forces? And then the biographers wonder at riddles and contradictions — I wonder that in such a conflict of forces there were so few of them. The curse of the Jew in modern society — that never and nowhere, save in the field of what is purely a matter of craft in trade and in science, can he put forward his whole, full, true self, because this society in its narrowness will tolerate a reflection of itself sooner than a native individuality, even though that individuality did not grow upon the same soil and under the same conditions — this curse of the half and the constrained lay still more heavily upon the baptized Jew Disraeli, who had the ambition to govern the most Christian nation in the world. Hence nothing is whole, nothing absolutely true, nothing spoken out to its last consequences in Disraeli's speeches and writings; not one of the three forces comes singly and wholly into effect, but is always checked and brought to a standstill halfway by the other two. Toward Judaism, too, Disraeli had no entirely sincere relation; he could have none. He had the choice between love and hatred; he might, like most Christians of Jewish descent before him, have attested his new faith by a zealous slandering of the old, he might have proved his adherence to the new nationality by the disparagement of the old — and, as history teaches, this method has as yet harmed no new Christian. Did Disraeli perhaps hold too good an opinion of the English to expect success from such a course? Did he foresee the coming of religious liberalism and order his relation to Judaism accordingly? The people who saw in Disraeli a mere calculating machine would perhaps have been inclined to find in his repeatedly emphasized Jewish descent a proof of shrewd foresight and of great
