Die Welt · Vol. I, No. 1 · 4 June 1897
6printed page
scan 10 of 20

Page 6. — "Die Welt" — No. 1.

Admission of Members.

With the adoption of the resolution the meeting should, in point of business, have been at an end. But the enthusiasm was such that a portion of those present desired to join at once as members. The Committee therefore had sheets circulated, upon which the members entered their names and addresses.

After the list of members had been handed over to the provisional Secretary, Rabbi Kopfstein addressed a few further words to the assembly, in which he begged them to agitate for the beautiful purpose within the circle of their friends and acquaintances, and to bring new members and adherents to the association now created.

Register Ferdinand Levy thereupon closed the sitting, and those present withdrew in an elevated frame of mind and in the consciousness of having consecrated an evening to a holy cause.


Christians on the Jewish Question.

The editorial staff of the "Welt" has addressed the following circular inquiry to several writers and politicians?

  1. What do you think of Zionism?
  2. Do you not believe that it can better the lot of the Jewish masses and do away with the Jewish question once and for all?
  3. Do you not believe that it is in the interest of Turkey to obtain for Palestine a numerous agricultural, tax-paying Jewish population, and to grant this population a certain autonomy?
  4. Do you not believe that the European States ought to approve such a solution of the Jewish question through the recognition, under international law, of a Jewish commonwealth established in Palestine with the consent of Turkey?

Reply of Prince Friedrich Wrede.

What do I think of Zionism?

Have you never, on an autumn ramble through the high-timbered forest, come suddenly upon a woodland meadow strewn with flowers of splendid colour?

Take care — for you have come into the neighbourhood of a swamp!

Have you never stood upon the bank of a reed-grown pond, on whose blue mirror of water single white water-lilies nodded dreamily?

Do not by any means let yourself be tempted to plunge into the crystal flood — for the shallow bottom is covered with grey slime and treacherous algae, which might wind themselves about your foot and fetter you for ever in the depths.

What the pale autumn crocuses are upon the woodland clearing, what the white lilies are upon the mirror of the water — that is Zionism in the picture of modern society.

A poetical, beautiful flower, which permits us to infer slime close at hand and gloomy misery.

What, in this case, forms the ugly swamp? What furnishes the turbid precondition of so unworldly a phenomenon as Zionism undeniably is?

Is it the simple race-antipathy of the Aryan against the Semite?

I hardly think so.

I take pleasure in holding far too high an opinion of the human race to ascribe so far-reaching an influence to differences of race.

For every instinctive hatred is something absolutely ugly.

It is even more reprehensible than something ugly — it is petty.

A petty thought, however, will never set the masses in motion. Only two things are able to do that: strong ideals and questions of existence.

No one will call anti-Semitism an ideal. I mean now that which is commonly designated as anti-Semitism.

Is it, then, a question of existence?

I will readily admit that among the Semites the level of the average intelligence is higher than among my own kinsmen. But no one is entitled to think so meanly of us Aryans as to suppose that there lies in this any immediate danger for us. The less so, as the Semitic superiority is confined to quite definite fields.

Since anti-Semitism, on the one hand, undeniably rules the masses, while on the other it can pass neither as a moral ideal nor as a threatening question of existence, there must be an error somewhere in the reckoning.

To pursue this error is not the task of these lines. I should only like to intimate thus much: that even to-day many millions of good people imagine the seat of love and of hatred to be in the heart, although science proves that this organ stands in no immediate connection with the processes of the soul. Here likewise we have to do with a usage of speech which is rooted far too deeply to be extirpated.

Nor does that alter the fact that anti-Semitism exists, and directs itself against all Jews, wholesale and without distinction.

A part of the Israelites is weary of this rôle which they are compelled to play — who could blame them for it — and gives notice to the host peoples that the tenancy is at an end.

Jerusalem — the old, glorious Jerusalem — shall arise again.

A thoroughly modern State is to be founded. A virgin commonwealth, whose members will be recruited partly from the despairing, partly from a self-sacrificing, enthusiastic intelligence.

For upon this we must be clear: the leading class in New Jerusalem will be formed by the intellectually free of Israel. Superabundantly, this State will or would, by its geographical situation, signify the door to that dark East which our civilisation must either soon conquer or be shattered by.

What a wealth of hopes! What rich possibilities!

May and can Europe suffer that?

Herewith we should have arrived at the fourth point of your inquiry.

If the Jews are in fact a people, as the Zionists maintain, then they will assuredly obtain their State. The principle of nationality has proved itself brilliantly in politics. Great, self-contained groups of peoples secure the peace.

The Jew who strives towards Jerusalem, and who should be held fast by European statesmen from self-interested motives, would be certain of the sympathy of all moral men.

He must only will it in earnest!

Will he do so?

In the course of the centuries Israel has not lacked opportunity to break, at least in part, the iron bonds of the Diaspora. I should like, for example, only to recall that Jewish Duke of Naxos who upon the ruins of Tiberias erected homesteads for his co-religionists.

To be sure, an undertaking which has failed ninety-nine times may succeed at the hundredth attempt.

Whether Israel is still a people, or only a religious communion — that it alone is able to answer.

Its attitude towards Zion will teach it in the nearest future.

I repeat it: if the Jews are a people, they will obtain their State.

The map would then be the richer by a bounded territory, the capitals of Europe by a palace of diplomacy; but the poetry of the people would be the poorer by one great stilled longing.

Perhaps the development of the spirit is of greater importance than that of the State.

And does not a poet say: O God! Preserve unto me my longing!

Friedrich, Prince Wrede.