Altneuland · Vol. II, No. 2 · February 1905
51printed page
scan 23 of 36

— 51 —

and after long negotiations, the Egyptian Government declared that it was not possible for it to hold to the understanding, because the opinion of the experts had warned it against doing so, since the plain could not be provided with sufficient water, and consequently no confidence could be placed in the colonization of El-Arish or the other parts of the peninsula . . . . . And the project was abandoned, since from the thorough investigations of the technical commission sent to El-Arish the impossi- bility of procuring adequate irrigation was made clearly evident; nor could the rain-water have met this serious requirement, since in those districts it rains seldom and but little."

In spite of the numerous and vehement opposition, the Congress approved the action of the Committee and resolved to direct its researches toward the colonization of the African territory, renouncing that of El-Arish.¹)

Now I wished once more to address a request to the commission which visited El-Arish, to the effect, namely, that its technical report might be published; this would not be without profit for geographical research. As for myself — being at present occupied with a study of Arabia Petraea — I hold the attempt at a colonization on that coast of the Mediterranean neither impossible, nor indeed lying in the distant future.


The Governorate of El-Arish is the easternmost of the six Mehâfzat of Egypt, and comprises the Mediterranean district beyond the Canal of Suez as far as the borders of Palestine. This zone of the desert, which slopes gently down from the mountain massif of Sinai toward the sea, was unanimously regarded, before the cutting of the Isthmus was pierced — and by one or another afterwards as well²) — as an appurtenance of Egypt; and this arose not so much from the uni- form aspect of the configuration of the ground from the Delta to Palestine, as from the intention of uniting the traditional and biblical boundary of the Wadi El-Arish (torrens Aegypti) and the conventional political boundary El-Refa—'Akaba.

But since the Isthmus of Suez — which consists of recent alluvium — represents the natural geographical and geological boundary between Africa and Asia and between Egypt and Arabia Petraea, we must regard the district of El-Arish, which forms a part of Arabia Petraea,³) as an appurtenance of Syria-Palestine. There are many reasons which justify this assignment. "From the Gulf of Alexandretta as far as Egypt," writes Reclus, "there extends a natural region which falls into three territories clearly separated from one another by formation of terrain, climate, and historical development;


¹) I owe these communications to the kindness of Mr. Benvenuto Donati of Modena, present director of the "Idea Sionista," as well as to a number of the latter (Sept./Oct. 1903) which was devoted to the Basle Congress. ²) Bertacchi, Vol. V of Terra v. Martinelli; Vidal de la Blache, Cours de Géo- graphie; Vivien de Saint-Martin, Dictionnaire. ³) I regard as the boundaries of Arabia Petraea the Canal and the Gulf of Suez, the Gulf of 'Akaba and the Wadi El-Araba, and the line from El-Rafa to the foot of the Dead Sea. This is not the place to set forth the reasons which have led me to fix these boundaries, and I reserve this for my monograph on Arabia Petraea.