Altneuland · Vol. I, No. 11 · November 1904
323printed page
scan 7 of 36
Facsimile · scan 7 of 36
Scan of p. 323
English · AI translation, checked against the German

— 323 —

carrying-through of the principle would leave the antagonism between capital and wage labour untouched at its core, and the social problem would await its solution as before; — and finally it is the worst utopianism, nay naïveté, to hope for such a general carrying-through from any propaganda, however comprehensive and enthusiastic. With him who in economic life still reckons with other mass forces — single exceptions have no mass effect — than the self-interest of the possessing classes and the pressure which the economic and political power of the coalesced non-possessing classes exerts upward, there is no arguing any longer.1)

But, all this conceded, so much of the idea yet remains that one may recognize profit-sharing, for certain suitable kinds of undertakings, as a form of labour-remuneration superior to the pure wage system. It heightens the self-interest of the worker in such measure that the net profit of the enterprise can grow strongly enough to place the worker and the employer also in a better position.

Such enterprises suited to profit-sharing are above all those in which quality work is to be performed, work which beyond the expenditure of raw strength demands strained attention and the most delicate care. That is not to be obtained from simple wage labourers, and so it is characteristic that the first and most famous enterprise which carried through profit-sharing with success, the house of Leclaire in Paris, was a great house-painting undertaking employing almost none but quality workers, and that the grandest German example concerns the firm of Zeiss in Jena, whose products in the field of precision mechanics and optics derive their enormous market value only to the very minutest fraction from the material employed, and almost wholly from the most highly qualified wage labour that is perhaps performed today upon the whole planet.

Further, there are suited to profit-sharing such enterprises in which a constant supervision of the workers is not possible. With the prospect of profit one gives them, so to speak, an inner overseer and driver to accompany them to the place of work, who renders the outer one dispensable. For this reason profit-sharing has on various occasions proved itself very well in mining; and in the case of Leclaire also this element must have strongly

  1. For further details on the theoretical position of profit-sharing see my "Siedelungsgenossenschaft," Berlin 1896, pp. 90 ff.