Altneuland · Vol. I, No. 5 · May 1904
130printed page
scan 6 of 36

— 130 —

undertaken on a small scale, and as such they have their unmistakable significance for the further development of things. That the results turned out so meagre is explained by the lack of system. The want of system, the lack of unity and consistency in the experiments undertaken, can even go so far that such experiments become child's play and not only can lead to no result, but in many cases must have a directly harmful effect.

To those acquainted with the colonization of Palestine hitherto it is by no means a secret that up to now colonization has proceeded at haphazard, and in many cases it must be called a miracle that experiments sprung from accidental occasions led to a positive result. Ignorance of the country of colonization, the unsuitability of the colonizing material, the fortuitousness in the choice of the leading personalities — these are generally known facts. Only the idealism of the pioneers and the enormous funds expended upon the colonization have been able to bring it about that now, after all the failures, we can call our own a stock of 27 colonies with about 6000 souls and 40,000 ha of land. The want of system showed itself in the settling of people without means, as also in the fortuitousness of the crops introduced, the carelessness with regard to the marketing of the products raised, the ignorance of the legal conditions of the territory to be colonized, and so forth. These defects have been censured so often that it is certainly superfluous to dwell upon them longer. What matters to us here is to emphasize the accidental, the unsystematic character of the colonization hitherto. It was spontaneous motives that brought it forth in the eighties of the last century — even though its inner causes must be sought much deeper and earlier — events which found our people without a proper understanding for this work.

We see, then, that with regard to the existing colonization it is not the expression "small," but rather "systemless," that must be applied. If, therewith, the incorrectness of the expression "small-scale" colonization should be evident, it remains to prove that a "large-scale" colonization cannot exist in and of itself, and can only result as the consequence of positive outcomes of systematic, purposeful, methodical experiments and preparatory labours — that large-scale colonization, therefore, is consistently to be understood as "systematic" colonization in contrast to the