Altneuland · Vol. I, No. 2 · February 1904
5scan
of 36

ALTNEULAND

A MONTHLY REVIEW for the economic development of Palestine Organ of the Zionist Commission for the Exploration of Palestine

PUBLISHED BY F. OPPENHEIMER · S. SOSKIN · O. WARBURG.

No. 2. Berlin, February 1904. Year I.

HARMONIOUS AND DISHARMONIOUS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES.

By Dr. Franz Oppenheimer.

The proposal to carry out the colonization of Palestine under the form of the agricultural workers' productive co-operative society commonly meets with objections drawn from the history of the industrial workers' productive co-operative society. I hold this obvious objection to be entirely without substance, and shall attempt to give detailed grounds for my opinion; and indeed I intend in a first essay to demonstrate that the fundamental psychological conditions of the two kinds of co-operative society are polar opposites of one another, and then in a second essay to show how, upon this differing foundation, entirely different conditions of existence arise — thereby at the same time furnishing the proof that the psychological analysis exhausts the reality.

Sociology, as the science of human collective life (in contrast to biology, as the science of human individual life), can find its foundation only in a fully developed collective psychology; for all human action, that is, all purposeful activity, proceeds from motives or — what is the same thing — aims at the satisfaction of needs; and thus the science of human collective action must everywhere go back to the science of the needs of the masses.

Of such needs there are several. The table of motives which is set up by many political economists — as, for example, by the meri-