247
…lives, that is — is loyal. Whether I am loyal in a despotism or in a Weitlingian “society”, it is the same rightlessness, inasmuch as in both cases I have not my right, but an alien right.
With right one always asks: “What or Who gives Me the right to it?” Answer: God, love, reason, nature, humaneness, &c. No, only thy force, thy power gives Thee the right (thy reason, e.g., may give it Thee).
Communism, which assumes that human beings “by nature have equal rights”, refutes its own proposition so far as to show that human beings by nature have no right at all. For it will not, e.g., acknowledge that parents have “by nature” rights against their children, or these against those: it abolishes the family. Nature gives parents, brothers and sisters, &c., no right at all. Altogether, this whole revolutionary or Babeuvian principle *) rests on a religious, i.e. false, view. Who, unless he too stands upon the religious standpoint, can ask after “right”? Is not “right” a religious concept, i.e. something sacred? “Equality of right”, as the Revolution set it up, is indeed only another form for “Christian equality”, the “equality of the brethren, of the children of God, of the Christians, &c.”, in short fraternité. Each and every question after right deserves to be scourged with Schiller’s words:
For years already I have made use of my nose for smelling; Have I then really a demonstrable right to it too?
*) Cf.: “Die Communisten in der Schweiz”, Commissionalbericht. p. 3.