Additions to the Essay on Holy Things 41
…mentioned above, from what we say in Zevahim (29): all holy things that were slaughtered before the opening of the Sanctuary are unfit. And he also raised a difficulty against the view of Rabbi Yohanan, that one who slaughters outside in this time is liable, because it was sanctified for the time to come: but there are no doors! And it follows a fortiori: if at a time when there are doors, which are fit for closing and fit for opening, it is unfit, all the more so where there are no doors. And I replied that Tosafot in Yoma (63) raised a difficulty like this from an altar that was damaged, and did not raise a difficulty against Rabbi Yohanan from the opening of the Sanctuary. But Rashba raised this difficulty from the entrance of the Sanctuary, and answered that where there is no entrance and no door, we have no difficulty with it. And I explained his answer: if there is a Sanctuary and an entrance, then it is closed before the Shekhinah and is not called "before Yahweh", and therefore they are unfit; but where there is no House at all, the Shekhinah has not moved from the place of the Ark, and behold, it is open and not closed, and it is "before Yahweh". And therefore Tosafot did not raise a difficulty from this, nor against "we offer sacrifices even though there is no House", and their difficulty is well answered.
- The Gaon of Altona mentioned above raised a difficulty to me against my way, from the order of the prayer (Megillah 17): "And once Jerusalem is built, David comes, etc.; and once David comes, prayer comes, as it is said, 'And I will bring them, etc.'; and once prayer comes, the Service comes, as it is said, 'Their burnt-offerings and their sacrifices, etc.'" Thus this verse is said of the time after the coming of the Messiah, and this is proof that no sacrifice is acceptable until the Temple is built through the coming of the Messiah son of David. Thus far his words. And I replied to him (besides what I brought above, section 4, clear proofs that it will be acceptable if we have the ability and the permission to perform the Service): behold, I have already brought proofs from the Midrash and from the Zohar that several redemptions will take place in the future, as written in portion Pinhas, that four redemptions are destined to be; and so the Midrash wrote on "And Pharaoh's cup was in his hand"; and so I wrote that there are four, corresponding to the parts of the time, in portion Vayishlah in the holy Zohar, on "She that looks forth like the dawn, fair as the moon, pure as the sun, awesome as the bannered hosts": behold, four. And therefore our prayer is founded on two sides: the first, the complete redemption after the son of David; the second, the first and second mentioned above. And the arrangement of the Men of the Great Assembly is a proof for my way: that after the Blessing of the Years, for of it is written, "And you, mountains of Israel, you shall give your branches to my people Israel" (as is written in Sanhedrin (98), that this is the sign of redemption, when the mountains of Israel yield their fruit to Israel through a small ingathering), there comes afterwards a great ingathering, "who gathers the dispersed of Israel", and as in the words of Nahmanides, "I will yet gather to him, besides his gathered ones"; and perforce there will be a small ingathering before the great ingathering, and afterwards, to whom would it give its fruit, which is the sign of redemption? And after the great ingathering, which will be through Messiah son of Joseph, Gog will surely come and execute judgment upon the wicked, as is written in the Talmud there, and afterwards David will come and build Jerusalem with a wall of fire. And so it is concerning the Service of sacrifice: two times. First, an altar without a Sanctuary, for the needs of the communal sacrifices, as in what is said, "A new altar shalt thou prepare in Zion, and the fine flour of the New Moon we shall offer up upon it", which is a communal sacrifice; and afterwards, after the coming of David, "in the Service of the Temple we shall all rejoice", when the individuals too bring peace-offerings of rejoicing and freewill sacrifices to be accepted; and such a complete Service, acceptable for all who offer freely, will be after the Messiah son of David, and therefore they placed this complete Service after "the Shoot of David". And so in prayer there are two aspects, for the Talmud said, "And once the son of David comes, prayer comes"; and it is difficult: is there then no prayer nowadays? Surely three times every day we say, "For thou hearest the prayer of every mouth"! Rather, there are certainly two sides to this: the prayer that we pray belongs to our time, but in the future prayer will come that will be fulfilled at once, the prayer of one who comes to the Sanctuary, as Solomon asked when he built the Sanctuary; and more so in the future, that it will be
