Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion, Jerusalem Edition · 1919
78scan
of 139

Additions to the Essay on Holy Things

…at one opinion on this, as it is in his pleasant book on Sukkah, which he sent me in his kindness. But on the second difficulty, that the building of the Sanctuary does not override the Sabbath and festival, I answered that Rabbi Eliezer follows his own view, for he holds that the preparations for a commandment override the Sabbath and festival, and even the Rabbis concede that the preparations for the Omer override them; see there. And on this the Gaon, may his light shine, raised a difficulty to me from what we say in Yevamot (17), that we derive from You shall keep my Sabbaths and reverence my sanctuary that the building of the Temple does not override the Sabbath, and the same applies to a festival; and I answered him that I had already noticed this in his book there, and he wrote that this holds only in the Tabernacle, when they offered on a high place, and likewise in the Sanctuary of the Second Temple, when they offered on the altar twenty-two years before the Temple; if so, this is not a preparation for the commandment of the Service of the Omer, since they could offer without a Sanctuary; which is not so when permission is given to build an altar: then the altar is a preparation for the Service.

And in the substance of the matter he agreed with me that the building of the future will be by the hands of men, and the spirituality of the Sanctuary above will come into the Sanctuary built by men. Only, his way inclined thus in Kodesh Mordecai, for he said that it will be built by the Messiahs, Messiah son of David and Messiah son of Joseph, who will be the craftsmen of the Temple; and I brought a proof against this: that at the hour when the son of David comes, and all his holy ones with him, then the earth will be full of knowledge; and how then can any decree apply that our Sages of blessed memory decreed concerning the eating of new grain, or such as "when they go wrong in the song", stated in Sukkah and Rosh Hashanah and in Beitzah 6, and likewise the apprehension of the Jerusalem Talmud regarding second tithe, cited in our books? And how can all this have any place after the coming of Messiah son of David and Elijah and all the patriarchs? And what have we gained by the answer of us both to the difficulty of Rashi and Tosafot mentioned above? It must certainly be according to our way: that first the altar will be built, before Gog comes, when they will have acquired cattle and goods, as is said in Ezekiel, and as is found in the Jerusalem Talmud, and other proofs; and then all the apprehensions that our Sages of blessed memory decreed apply; and when Messiah son of David comes and builds the Sanctuary in its completeness, then a Sanctuary of fire will come from above, and all flesh will see its light shining upon the Sanctuary below, speedily in our days, amen. And so it is proven from Tosafot, Pesahim (114), at the heading "One etc.": "that there is no need to fear lest the Temple be built, etc., for the offering is entrusted to the diligent, and when it is built Moses and Aaron will be with us, and there is no room for error." End of their words.

And behold, my friend the keen Rabbi, a basket full of books, our teacher Rabbi Hayyim Mordecai of Plock, author of the book Likkutei Mordecai, raised a difficulty against my way from the Tosafot mentioned above: why did he write that there is no room for error? Surely there is room for error when the altar is built before Moses and Aaron come. And I answered him that there in Pesahim it speaks of the festival offering, as is found there in the passage, and the festival offering does not come in impurity; and when the altar is built, only a communal sacrifice, which comes in impurity, will be permitted, but the festival offering will not be permitted until the Messiah comes and we have the ashes of the Heifer. And if so, from Tosafot there is a proof for my way, that in the days of the Messiah there is no room for error; and therefore every decree of our Sages of blessed memory is for our time.

And afterwards the Rabbi Hayyim Mordecai mentioned above informed me that he found in the book Bigdei Aharon, on the portion Ve-Zot ha-Berakhah, in the name of the book Tuv ha-Arets, that the order of the redemption will be in this manner: that the building of the Temple will be before the war of Gog and Magog; and see there, where he enlarges greatly on this. End of his words. And consequently the Sanctuary will be before the coming of David, as I brought above from the Jerusalem Talmud and from the holy Zohar, portion Toledot, that the Temple precedes the ingathering; see there.

  1. The great Rabbi, keen and learned, our teacher Rabbi Hayyim Mordecai, may his light shine, mentioned above, argued against my way (which is also the way of the Gaon of Altona mentioned above) that the building of the Temple is first by the hands of men; and these are his words: Are not the words of Rashi, that the future building is by the hands of Heaven, from the Midrash Tanhuma, as Tosafot wrote