Essay on Holy Things
…all hidden things are revealed, ordered in all things and secure, and from his well his disciples, who draw water from his buckets, will draw; and I am compelled to burden him further with the trouble of my letter, for it is Torah and I need to learn, and from Heaven his reward will be double.
Our master, may his light shine, expressed astonishment at Maharashdam for being lenient with the priests of our time in the case of a captive woman on the word of a witness from the mouth of a witness, and held that their being called first to the Torah is a custom, and that in truth they stand on presumption and do not escape the realm of doubt, and are obliged by law to fulfil the positive commandment "and thou shalt sanctify him", and to be stringent in all the priestly prohibitions. And he dwelt at length on sound proofs against him, and our master has ruled well for us as to the law. But in the words of Ribash he was forced into a strained reading, that what he wrote, "they were accustomed", is according to the law; and in my humble opinion this can be reconciled without strain. For the Rabbi, the Maggid, wrote (in chapter 20 of the Laws of Forbidden Relations, halakhah 3) on the words of Maimonides, "One who comes at the present time and says, I am a priest, is not believed, and is not called to the Torah": and the Maggid wrote, "And I have seen one who raised a difficulty against our master in these words: Our custom is to call him first, and so reason dictates, for it does not matter to us if he reads first. What would you say — lest they rise from the reading of the Torah to heave-offering? We are not so much concerned about rabbinic heave-offering. Thus far. And I say: one does not bring proof from a mistaken custom; and nevertheless it is possible that, because heave-offering is not practised in our lands, they were not concerned about believing him for the reading of the Torah; and even so it is not fitting to do so." End of the words of the Maggid. And according to this the difficulty our master, may his light shine, raised against Ribash — but surely there is a doubtful positive commandment of "and thou shalt sanctify him"! — is resolved; and one may say: because there is reason to fear that they will rise from the reading of the Torah to rabbinic heave-offering in a place where it is practised, it would have been fitting to transgress a doubtful positive commandment on account of this concern. For even a certain positive commandment the Sages have power to uproot for the sake of a rabbinic decree, all the more so a doubtful positive commandment; only that they have already become accustomed not to be concerned about this, to say, lest they be lenient in eating the holy things of the provinces. Therefore he wrote that for the sake of a remedy they were accustomed not to abolish the priesthood on account of this concern, and in the language cited in the Maggid mentioned above.
But I am astonished at Ribash, for it is against Maimonides mentioned above, who wrote there: at the present time he is not believed on his own word, but on the word of one other witness he is believed, to read first and to eat the holy things of the provinces. So it is explicit that, to be lenient in eating the holy things of the provinces, which are forbidden to non-priests, we also hold him to be a full priest. And one cannot say that Maimonides speaks of the time of the Talmud and not of our generations; that is not so, for if so there would be no place for any of the words of the Maggid, neither the difficulty nor its resolution, arguing from the custom of the present time to the time of the Talmud. And moreover, this chapter of Maimonides refers to our time, as he wrote there: the dough-offering too, the priests of our time eat it on presumption. And harder still, he wrote there (halakhah 13): "One who comes at the present time, etc., and forbids himself a divorced woman, etc., and if he married or became impure, he is flogged." End of his words. And it is obvious that one does not punish on a doubt, and also one does not punish on a man's own word unless he has been presumed so for thirty days, as the Mishneh la-Melekh wrote there and as Maimonides wrote (end of chapter 1 of the Laws of Forbidden Relations); and if so it is explicit that also for leniency we hold him a certain priest if he has been presumed so only thirty days, for everywhere the punishment of flogging is like capital punishment. However, through the reasoning of our master a path has lit up for me to reconcile the view of Ribash and of the Magen Avraham; and it is what our master said above, that in the lifting of the hands, since there is a positive commandment, we rely on presumption, even though there is a doubt that he transgresses a positive commandment if he is not a priest, for this too is a doubt that he transgresses a positive commandment if he is a priest. And if so, in the case before us too, since there is a positive commandment to punish one who is liable to punishment. (As we find in Shabbat 107, that a scriptural derivation is needed that execution by the court does not override the Sabbath.) Therefore they left him