Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion and First to Zion · 1866
56scan
of 88

Essay on Holy Things

…when they came up from the exile in the time of the Second Temple; end of his words. Here it is explicit that only because of a clear flaw did they need to establish their lineage, but had there been no flaw we would have relied on presumption without establishing lineage. And what is said in the Talmud there, that he permitted them only the holy things of the provinces, that was at the time of the clear flaw, as Rashi explained; but after they had already been clarified and made clean in the days of the Second Temple by a court of priests, by bringing near and putting away, the flaw departed, and we rely on the majority by Torah law. And likewise the Yam shel Shelomo, which our master cited as being stringent in the matter of devoted things, wrote, "if not the majority, then close to half became confused"; here even the Rashal, who went far too much beyond the measure, nevertheless held that most of them are fit. And by Torah law we certainly follow the majority, and the Rabbis made a higher standard in matters of lineage; and only where there is no positive commandment against it did they make a higher standard, to require lineage of them; but wherever there is the neglect of a positive commandment it remains on the law of the Torah, that we rely on majority and presumption. And according to this, in the case before us.

If we shall have permission to minister in holiness, there is certainly a great positive commandment of the Service, and where a positive commandment would be neglected we rely on the law of the Torah; and if so there is also no proof from the Responsa Hut ha-Shani and those who join it, who were stringent with them in a thing forbidden to non-priests, for all of them speak of a case without the neglect of a positive commandment, which is not so in the case before us.

And if one should argue that only where there is already a positive commandment do we rely on Torah law, but to perform an act, to build an altar and to perform a positive commandment and to rely on presumption, whence do we know it? There are two replies to this. First, that in Pesahim 69 it is proved that a positive commandment overrides even though one is not yet obligated, as with an uncircumcised man who has not circumcised himself, who is liable to excision for the positive commandment of the Passover offering, as the Talmud says there explicitly for this reason. And further, even today there is a positive commandment of the Service, only that there is a hindrance and constraint on the part of the government there; but when there is permission, for we hold that it was sanctified for the time to come, then so long as there is any way in the world to bring about the possibility of permission, we transgress a positive commandment every single day, and consequently we rely on the law of the Torah. And further, for building an altar there is likewise a positive commandment, if it be permitted us; and since there is a positive commandment to build, consequently there is also a positive commandment of the Service as of old; and this is clear. And further it seems to me, in my humble opinion, that since by Torah law we certainly follow majority and presumption, our Sages of blessed memory cannot at all uproot a positive commandment of the Torah where it is not possible with those of attested lineage, for if so the commandment would be uprooted altogether; and indeed the Magen Avraham, in section 589, subsection 4, wrote that where the commandment would be uprooted forever we do not make an ordinance; for the power that our Sages of blessed memory have to uproot holds only occasionally, such as not to blow the shofar on the Sabbath of this year, but to uproot the commandment forever, no. And if so, how shall we uproot the Service forever for the sake of a higher standard?

And further it seems to me that even those who are excessively stringent agree that an examination of four mothers is effective, as Rabbenu Tam ruled in the Sefer ha-Yashar, cited in Tosafot, chapter Asarah Yuhasin, folio 76, on the words beginning "He must examine", see there, that examination is effective even with regard to the Service, which is more stringent. And this is exact in the language of the Magen Avraham, section 457, subsection 9, who wrote on the view of the stringent in the matter of hallah for a priest, and these are his words: "that we do not hold him to be a certain priest, for perhaps one of his mothers was profaned; and so wrote the Rashal and Mahari"; end of his words. Here he did not take as the reason of the doubt that they became confused and he is not a priest at all, for certainly we are not concerned about that against majority and presumption; only that we are stringent on account of one of his mothers, as we find with the Service; therefore the custom is not to give them to eat. And besides all that is mentioned above, I have already brought