Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion and First to Zion · 1866
48scan
of 88

Essay on the Service

…in purity, nevertheless, if all of them are impure through the dead, they may offer all the communal sacrifices, such as the Passover offering, and the daily offering morning and evening, and the additional offering of the Sabbath and the New Moon, and the goats of the festivals, the meal-offering of the Omer, and the Two Loaves, and the Shewbread, even though there are no ashes of the Heifer. Know this: for even the one who says that it is overridden for the community disagrees only in that we seek to bring pure ones from another father's house, as we say in Yoma, folio 6; but if there are none at all, he certainly concedes that they perform it in impurity; and this is plain and clear. And if the objector should argue: behold, before we wish to offer sacrifice, when we come to seek the place of the altar and to build it, how shall we go there in impurity, not at a time of the Service, and who will build it? This too is no question. The halakhah has already been decided that for the needs of building the Sanctuary and the Temple, to repair its breaches, impure persons may enter there if there are no pure ones; and so Maimonides wrote, chapter 6 of the Laws of the Chosen House, halakhah 3, and this is his language: "At the time when the builders enter to build and to repair in the Sanctuary, or to remove impurity from there, the duty falls on priests without blemish; and if there are none without blemish, etc., the duty falls on pure persons; and if there are no pure persons, impure persons may enter." End of his language. And if in the Sanctuary, whose holiness is greater, it is permitted to impure persons, how much more in the Court, for the building of the altar, is it permitted to impure persons, since there are no pure ones.

  1. The third obstacle: to find a priest of attested lineage; and at first thought this is reckoned as a strange thing according to the Talmud and Maimonides. But I shall bring, with Yahweh's help, clear proofs for permitting it. It is true that a very few are found who still have their record of lineage going back to one of the High Priests, but they are a minority of a minority. However, we shall make clear, with Yahweh's help, that when we need priests for the Service, all of them are in the presumption of fitness, unless some defect has become known in him. And the clear proof is that we have learned in Eduyot, chapter 8, mishnah 7: "Rabbi Joshua said: I have received from Rabban Yohanan ben Zakkai, who heard from his teacher, and his teacher from his teacher, a law given to Moses at Sinai, that Elijah does not come to declare impure or pure, to bring near or to put away, but to bring near those put away by force and to put away those brought near by force. The family of Beit Tzerifah was on the other side of the Jordan, and the sons of Zion put it away by force; and there was yet another family there, and the sons of Zion brought it near by force. Such as these Elijah comes to put away and to bring near. Rabbi Judah says: to bring near, but not to put away." And the commentary of the Ra'av, and this is his language: "That Elijah does not come to clear up the doubt of the families, who has become mingled, but will leave them, and they are fit in the time to come, etc.; but a family that became mingled because its unfitness was not known, he will leave in its fitness." End of his language. From this we learn that every doubt in a family stands in the presumption of fitness for the time to come, so long as no defect has become known in them. And there are several wonders about this saying. 1) Is it then a halakhah for the Messiah? (as the Talmud objects several times). And why should a law given to Moses at Sinai come concerning the thing that Elijah will do? Surely when Elijah comes he will know what he is to do, and there is no practical consequence for us, but only for Elijah? 2) A difficulty: is not the truth known from Sinai, that in the time to come the book of genealogies will cease, and persons of attested lineage will not be found; and therefore Elijah will need to sift out priests of attested lineage and to inform us, "This is a fit priest, worthy to offer sacrifice"? And how can we say, as a law given to Moses at Sinai, that he does not come to bring near and to put away? How shall we know who is to offer sacrifice and who is to be held back and put from the priesthood as polluted? And if, apart from Elijah, it becomes known by the holy spirit who is the priest, then what will Elijah do? Surely even those brought near and those put away by force would become known by that same holy spirit?

To this it seems clear and right, according to our way which we stated above, that first there will be a gathering of the nobles of the people without a prophet, and we shall offer sacrifices on the altar of Yahweh; and afterwards Gog will come, and after