Tzvi Hirsch Kalischer · Seeking Zion · 1862
39scan
of 43

Essay on Holy Things 19

…that Rav Yosef holds it according to his own party, for the matter hangs on a dispute of the Amoraim. For in Sanhedrin 99 Samuel said: "There is no difference between this world and the days of the Messiah except subjection to the kingdoms alone"; that is, he disagrees there with Rabbi Yohanan, who said: "All the prophets prophesied only of the days of the Messiah; but as for the world to come, no eye has seen" etc. Rabbi Yohanan holds that all the good promises will be for the days of the Messiah, before the resurrection; but the delight of the world to come the prophets did not attain, just as they did not attain His essence, blessed be He, as it is written, "For man shall not see me and live"; so they did not see that delight which cleaves to Him, blessed be He. And Samuel holds that in the days of the Messiah the good and the freedom will come to Israel in our land in a natural and manifest way, but the great light, as in "Then the moon shall be confounded and the sun ashamed", will be after the resurrection. And Rabbi Hillel said there: "There is no Messiah for Israel"; and the correct explanation there is as the Kotev wrote in the introduction to Ein Yaakov, following Rashi's explanation: that there will be a redemption by the will of the kingdoms, which Yahweh, blessed be He, will put into the heart of them all, to have mercy on Israel and to lead them to their land in peace. And Rav Yosef says there: "May his Master forgive him! Is it not written, 'Thy king shall come to thee, poor, and riding upon the ass'?" And it is known that at such a time Elijah will come, according to the word of Malachi, peace be upon him; and if so, according to Rav Yosef there will be no redemption whatever until Elijah comes, and then everything will be known from the mouth of Elijah; and he rightly said "a halakhah for the Messiah". But the other Amoraim do not hold like Rav Yosef; and a proof of the matter that there is a dispute on this: for why did Rav Yosef not bring a plain verse, "And David my servant shall be prince over them for ever", behold, there is a Messiah for Israel? Rather, it must be that it never entered Rabbi Hillel's mind to deny the Messiah, God forbid, for if so they would have put him out of the house of study; but he certainly believed in all the words of the prophets (for they prophesied also after Hezekiah), and he said only that the principal redemption will spring forth without the Messiah, only through the will of the kingdoms, as in the words of the Kotev, and afterwards David and the son of David will come, according to the words of Ezekiel. And Rav Yosef disagrees with this and brings proof from "poor, and riding upon the ass": that while Israel are not yet in their glory he will come as a poor man; if so, this is the beginning of the redemption; and all the Amoraim disagree on this. Hence only Rav Yosef, according to his own party, said "a halakhah for the Messiah"; and Rabbi Yohanan too can hold like the Jerusalem Talmud, that the first sprouting of the redemption is through the kingdom, only that afterwards the Messiah will come and all the promises will be fulfilled in the days of the Messiah; and Samuel holds that in the days of the Messiah everything will be after the way of all the earth, and after the resurrection there will be new heavens and a new earth, and the like. And as to what further troubled the Rabbi, may his light shine, that Abaye too holds so: I wrote to him that Abaye answered him according to the party of Rav Yosef, but he himself does not hold so; and as Tosafot also wrote in Yoma 13, and these are their words: "For the Talmud does not take this as a fixed rule, 'a halakhah for the Messiah', but only Rav Yosef, who said so in the chapter 'Four Deaths' and in the chapter 'Beit Shammai'; but in the Talmud it is not concerned." Thus far their words. And as for what my friend wrote, that Rava too asked so: in truth in some books "Rava" is written in Zevahim, but in the accurate Talmud of the Gaon Rabbi Isaiah Pick it is written that it is Rav Yosef and not Rava; and as Tosafot wrote explicitly, that no authority holds so; and certainly he holds, as above, that Abaye answered him according to the party of Rav Yosef.

On the second answer of Tosafot, and so they explained it further in Yoma 13 there, that what is counted a sin is what comes in the matter of piggul: the explanation of their words is that certainly no such thing will be found in the time to come, that one would say explicitly that he renders it piggul, for piggul requires saying it with one's mouth, and on account of this our Sages of blessed memory imposed a penalty, that the one who renders it piggul should be made impure; but a sin-offering and a guilt-offering, which come through inadvertence, will certainly not cease until the spirit of impurity passes from the land; and how much more so in the case in Zevahim, which speaks of a High Priest who sins, and that is a remote eventuality at that time, the more so as there will be no High Priest at the beginning of the Service, as the Rabbi, may his light shine, also wrote, on account of the lack of the shamir and of the stones for the priestly garments of the High Priest. And therefore only there did Rav Yosef say "a halakhah for the Messiah", in a tone of wonder: will such laws really be needed for that time? And to this Abaye answered that even so, "expound and receive a reward", even in a matter that does not occur at all. And a proof of this: in Sanhedrin 51, where Rav Yosef objected "a halakhah for the Messiah", and Abaye answered him that in any case one should expound and receive a reward, and Rav Yosef said to him, "I am speaking of halakhah"; and Rashi explained, at the words "This is what I mean": "Why do I need a halakhah? etc. Does halakhah apply to such a dispute as this, in which there is between Rabin and Ravina neither liability nor exemption, etc., but they dispute about the correction of the wording of the baraita, etc.; when the Messiah comes and the dead live, we shall ask Rabbi Eliezer in which wording he said it." Thus far his words. And why did Rashi not explain, "I am speaking of fixing a halakhah"? God forbid! Rashi holds that Rav Yosef too agreed with Abaye that where there is a practical consequence for the law of the Service, one must learn it for when permission comes; only his difficulty was to explain the intention of Rabbi Eliezer, of whom we shall ask when the Messiah comes and the dead live. And although in many places we take pains to understand the mind of the holy ones even without a practical consequence, nevertheless where there are two things together, for the Messiah and the understanding of Rabbi Eliezer's intention, not for practical law, in such a case we do not take pains. And Abaye did not understand Rav Yosef's question, and supposed that it was proper to fix a halakhah at all; and he rightly objects to him that we find several such halakhot, and as Tosafot brought