Ninth Letter.
A Dilemma. — Sacred History of Mankind — Our Allies. — Unity of the Human Race. — Races and Types of Peoples. — Organism of Mankind. — Organ of Love.
You set up the dilemma that one must either, with the Luxemburg Hirsch, behold the aim and fundamental essence of Judaism in humanity; in which case it is not the national but the humane aim, as it appears in Freemasonry and in the Reform, that is worthy to be striven for; but then Judaism too, like every ecclesiastical or political association, is destined to be swallowed up in universal humankind. — Or else one must, with the Frankfort Hirsch, see in Judaism the exclusive salvation; in which case one stands in contradiction with the modern humanitarian aspirations, and may as little as orthodox Christianity appeal to the public opinion of our century, since it would listen to such an appeal with feelings like those with which it would hear a Chinese proclamation and a papal jeremiad.
I should think, dear friend, that the views which you have had set before you by me have as little in common with the Either as with the Or; they belong in fact to an altogether different order of ideas. I