46
…Judaism were, without forming a closed caste of priests or scholars. Though most of them, like our Jewish poets, are still too much carried away by the general current of levelling tendencies to think of the restoration of our nationality, yet with them, as with those, nothing more is needed than an impulse from without to see them also come forward as Jewish patriots, which at the bottom of their hearts they are. Danger threatened Judaism only from those religious reformers, happily now almost extinct, who with newly invented ceremonies and stale fine speaking sucked the last marrow out of Judaism, and left of this grandest phenomenon in the history of the world nothing but the shadow of a skeleton. It did not suffice them to further the endeavour after a Jewish doctrine standing at the height of modern science, and to satisfy the need of a more orderly and more aesthetic form of our ancient Jewish cultus. They nourished the wholly unseasonable, still-born idea, overheard from a foreign confession, of a reform of religion which has not the slightest ground either in the modern world at large, still less in the essentially national Judaism. — I do not fail to recognise the justification of the religious reform in the time of Luther in the Christian world, as also that of a reform rather aesthetic than religious or scientific in the time of Mendelssohn in the Jewish world. It never remotely entered the minds of those reformers to touch the historical basis of a cultus which cannot arbitrarily be replaced by a new one. Our present-day reformers, on the contrary, wished to reform this basis itself; their reform had only the negative meaning (if it had any meaning at all) of declaring unbelief in the national foundation of our religion. No wonder that it only indifferentism and apos-
