91
Whether animal sacrifice be regarded as a concession which our Torah was obliged to make to heathenism in order to prevent a relapse into it, or whether one see in the sacrificial cultus symbolic acts whose meaning and need we no longer know, this much is certain: the Jews, in spite of their "bloody sacrifices," upon which we to-day look down so loftily, had a greater awe of shedding and consuming the blood, "which is the life," than our modern peoples, who consume the blood with the flesh without sacrifice and without ceremonies. — But to be sure, the sacrificial cultus has not been the fashion for eighteen hundred years; therefore our new-fashioned Jews are ashamed of it. — Nevertheless it seems, even to-day, to be a natural expression of the pious, childlike heart. Göthe relates how in his youth he could satisfy his religious sense only by sacrifices which he offered to the Eternal, kindling a fire and throwing his dearest playthings into it. — On the other hand, our prophets of antiquity and rabbis of the Middle Ages never regarded the sacrificial service as so essential as do our rigid Orthodox of to-day, who hold it inseparable from the restoration of our nationality. — Already R. Jochanan ben Sakkai, pointing to the prophetic saying in Hos. VI. 6, declared that sacrifices could be replaced by works of charity, and more recent rabbinical authorities, who do not grant the Aaronites of to-day the right to officiate as sacrificing priests, nevertheless declare themselves for the restoration of the Jewish State.*) The cultus which we shall one day celebrate in the new Jerusalem can and must, therefore, remain an open question. Rome was not built in a day; the new Jerusalem, too, needs time for its giant structure. What we to-day
*) Note X.