89
…"perfections" of the beloved being, but loves it precisely as it is, with all its merits and defects — not because it seeks, say, to gloss over the latter, but because it loves the undivided individuality. The scar on the face of my beloved not only does no injury to my love, but is as dear to me, who knows? perhaps even dearer, than her beautiful eyes, which are found in other beauties too, whereas precisely this scar is characteristic of the individuality of my beloved. — Were the sacrificial cultus really inseparable from the Jewish nationality, I would accept it without further ado. But until now, and so long as I am not taught better, I am convinced of the contrary. In our sublime cultus of history, which advances from creation of light to creation of light, and which breathes only love of mankind and knowledge of God ¹), the sacrificial cultus can be nothing essential, nothing integral.
But in spite of my individual conviction, I would not presume to anticipate history. There are questions which are insoluble a priori, that is, before practice, but which solve themselves in the course of historical development. Among these questions is that of the cultus in general, and quite especially the formation of definite forms and norms of divine worship out of the moral and religious spirit of that people which, in every epoch of its development, was itself the creator of its religion.
Rabbi Sachs, whose classic work I have already once cited to you, says, where he speaks of the religious norms that grew rigid in exile, and, in contrast to this rigidity, brings out how they had arisen through a free historical development on the holy soil:
"The broad ground of an historical reality is not, by a system of norms complete from the very outset, to be encom-
