Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
45printed page
scan 59 of 434

45

wants one to be right in abhorring them. But the pre-existing fact is simply that the Jews are abhorred.

I must speak the painful word: the peoples who emancipated the Jews gave themselves over to a self-deception about their feelings. In order to exert its full effect, the emancipation had to be accomplished in feeling before it was pronounced in law. But that was not the case.

The opposite was the case. The history of Jewish emancipation is one of the most remarkable chapters in the history of European thought. The emancipation of the Jews is not the consequence of the insight that a tribe has been gravely wronged, that horrible things have been inflicted upon it, and that it is time to atone for a thousand-year injustice; it is solely the consequence of the straight-lined, geometrical way of thinking of 18th-century French Rationalism. This Rationalism constructed, with mere logic, without regard for living feeling, principles with the certainty of a mathematical axiom, and insisted on bringing these creations of pure reason to bear in the world of realities. "Sooner let the colonies perish than a principle!" goes the well-known cry that shows the application of the rationalist method to politics. The emancipation of the Jews represents another, almost automatic application of the rationalist method. The philosophy of Rousseau and the Encyclopedists had led to the declaration of the rights of man. From the declaration of the rights of man, the rigid logic of the men of the great upheaval derived the emancipation of the Jews. They set up a proper equation: every human being has by nature certain rights; the Jews are human beings; therefore, the Jews by nature have the rights of man. And thus in France, the equal rights of the Jews were pro-