Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
369printed page
scan 383 of 434

369 or makes itself unpleasantly noticeable through foolishness, inconsistency, hypocrisy, or cold-heartedness.

Mr. Dr. Hirsch wants to have nothing in common with a movement in which I also stand, because my company does not seem worthy enough for him. I do not know Mr. Dr. Hirsch and do not know whether I would have to regard his company as an honor or not. But I can assure him that it would in no case make me loathe Zionism, even if he professes to be a Zionist, even if he wanted to cooperate in the salvation of the Jewish people.

Mr. Dr. Hirsch wants to pick a fight with me because of my stance on matters of faith. But why did he use Zionism as a pretext? I have never claimed that Zionism is a matter of faith for me. I have always expressly said the opposite. I have always declared that I see in the Zionist movement a national-Jewish movement, which I may join because I belong to the Jewish race, to the Jewish people. The Jewish people includes pious keepers of tradition and freethinkers. They recognize each other as brothers despite this difference. They avoid speaking of what separates them, and they gladly dwell on what unites them. If Mr. Dr. Hirsch wants to do the opposite, this does not prove the strength of his faith, but rather the weakness of his Jewish sentiment.

Now to the other question. Be completely at ease about the non-Jewish colonization of the Holy Land. It will always remain only a hothouse plant that cannot last on its own strength. Rich support will perhaps entice small groups of Christian emigrants to set up their home in Palestine. Real attractive power

24