Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
354printed page
scan 368 of 434

produced a reduction of the monument by Grätz. He has managed to remain rather complete while still being concise. All in all, it is a small masterpiece of summarization, capturing the life and the works, the astonishing and terrible adventures, the tortures, the hopes, the efforts, and the disappointments of our people across twenty centuries and thirty countries in fewer than 380 pages, without lapsing into the dryness of name registries or the pedantry of a dull chronicler.

For he is by no means dry, this Mr. Theodor Reinach. He is eloquent. He is full of feeling. His account is lively. At times he is even seized by a touch of the grandiose, and many a page that tells of the martyrdom of our forefathers would look good even in the works of Michelet.

But a baffling circumstance emerges in this book. Four-fifths of it are dedicated to proving that the Jews, or the "Israelites," as Mr. Theodor Reinach prefers to call us with the delicacy of a modern Parisian, are a people, a nation, a scattered people, a nation without a land, but, as he excellently puts it, one "whose members are closely bound to one another by pious memories, by meticulously established religious customs fixed with jealous care, and finally by the books in which this religious paternal heritage is recorded." He could have added: "by common descent." But that would probably have troubled him, and so he avoided speaking of the bonds of blood that exist among the members of the Jewish family. For the first four-fifths of the book are followed by a final fifth, in which Mr. Theodor Reinach develops just as much energy to deny that the