Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
20printed page
scan 34 of 434

20 ═════════════════════════════════════════════════

When the philosophy for which Mendelssohn is known began to penetrate Judaism, things became different. Faith grew more lukewarm; the educated, insofar as they did not fall away completely, began to interpret the teachings of their religion rationalistically. For them, the dispersion of the Jewish people was a final and unalterable fact; they emptied the concepts of Messiah and Zion of all concrete content and concocted a peculiar doctrine, according to which the Zion promised to the Jews was to be understood only in a spiritual sense, as the establishment of Jewish monotheism for the whole world, as the eventual triumph of Jewish ethics over the less high and noble moral teachings of the other peoples. The Mendelssohnian Enlightenment consequently developed in the first half of the 19th century into the “Reform” movement, which consciously broke with Zionism. For the Reform Jew, the word Zion has as little meaning as the word dispersion. He does not feel himself to be in any diaspora. He denies that a Jewish people exists and that he is a member of it. He wishes to belong only to the people in whose midst he lives. For him, Judaism is a purely religious concept that has nothing whatsoever in common with nationality. His country of birth is his fatherland, and he does not wish to know another. The thought of a return to Palestine outrages him or provokes him to laughter. He counters it with the well-known silly joke: “If the Jewish state were to be re-established in Palestine, I would demand to be its ambassador in Paris.”

Thinking Jews have not failed to notice, in the long run, that Reform Judaism is a half-measure which, like every half-measure, carries within it the seed of its own downfall, since it cannot withstand logical criticism for a single moment. Whom is Reform Judaism supposed to satisfy? The