PATRIOTISM AND ZIONISM
("L'Echo Zioniste", 1903, No. 2. — From the French.)
There is an objection that has been held against Zionism from the very first day and that is raised against it again and again.
The objection is as follows: "As soon as you profess to be a Zionist, you thereby tacitly, indeed even explicitly, admit that you are a stranger in your country and that you desire nothing more ardently than to leave it, the sooner the better, to reach your true fatherland, Palestine. If this is so, however, then it would be strange on your part to complain that you are denied civil rights or that they are revoked in the countries where they have been generously granted to you. You justify in advance the governments that would go so far as to expel you from a country to which you are bound by no patriotic feeling."
These phrases were the answer to our first proclamations in writing and speech. We replied to them immediately. But our opponents acted as if they had not heard our reply, and so we see everywhere, where we convene a meeting with free discussion, some profound thinker emerge, who, certain of victory, starts the refrain: "Since you are a Zionist, you cannot be a patriot