Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
275printed page
scan 289 of 434

275

One can practice agriculture like a small farmer or like a great capitalist. The small farmer lives from hand to mouth. His plot of land must provide him every day with the food he needs every day, and every year with the harvest with which he can cover the year's expenses. The great capitalist can wait for years for a return; he can therefore undertake cultivations that bring in not a single penny for several years, but instead require large sums of money, and he is satisfied if after years he gets his capital back with interest.

Our colonists began, quite rightly and quite naturally, as small farmers, for they were poor, indeed in part completely destitute. Even small-scale farming did not sustain them at first, because they were inexperienced. Thus they fell into great distress. They would have been helped if benefactors had supported them moderately for a few years, until they had learned to live as independent, albeit poor, small farmers.

The famous great benefactor helped them differently. He induced them — what am I saying? — he imperiously commanded them to give up small-scale cultivation and to switch to large-scale capitalist cultivation. They were no longer to grow vegetables, wheat, barley, and raise livestock, but instead plant vines, fruit and olive trees, which for four, six, ten years would yield not a single penny of return.

The colonists obeyed the command of the great benefactor. They cheerfully planted vines and trees, waited for the plantings to yield a return, and in the meantime took from the hand of the great benefactor the wages on which they lived.

Suddenly the great benefactor declares that he wants nothing more to do with them and that he is giving no more money. What

18*