Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
267printed page
scan 281 of 434

267

...reverses the concentration of property in the hands of a few economically superior people and which elevates care for the poor, the widows, the orphans, even the strangers to a religious commandment? Who respects freedom as much as Jewish law, which condemns the slave to have his ear nailed to a doorpost if he is wretched enough to refuse the freedom legally restored to him after seven years? Where is manual labor, any honest work, more highly esteemed than in Judaism, whose greatest teachers and sages in the golden age of the Jewish spirit were shoemakers, carpenters, and masons, and who explicitly taught that it befits the nobleman of the spirit to earn his living through manual labor and, alongside it, to cultivate science for its own sake, not for reward? Do you believe it is a coincidence that at the cradle of modern socialism stand the Jews Marx and Lassalle, that even now Jews occupy a primary place among the theoreticians of socialism? These men may well have renounced their Judaism, but within them, unknown to them, a Jewish atavism prevails. From the most latent folk traditions, from which the primal dispositions of every individual are largely composed, they inherited that enthusiasm for social justice, which in their case took the form of rebellion against an unjust economic and social order and the development of the socialist program.

I believe I have now shown that the Jewish proletarians, as well as the Jewish theoreticians of socialism, will find ample, free space for all their legitimate aspirations in Zionism. But I also want to show them that, in the long run, they can only find this space in Zionism and not outside of Zionism.