Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
243printed page
scan 257 of 434

243

should become Mohammedans — I can spare myself from spinning out that thought further. This solution is unacceptable to the vast majority of the Jewish people. They cling to the faith of their fathers and live and die with the creed: Schema Israel adonai elohenu adonai echad. But I will let the argument of faith rest.

The proposal of assimilation also has aspects other than religious ones. We must ask ourselves: can the Jewish people, should the Jewish people, dissolve without a trace into the sea of nations? I am no fanatic. I sometimes wish I were, at least a little, for fanaticism is a great force. I admit that the Jewish people, like every other reported by world history, has a limited lifespan, that it is destined, like every ethnic organism, to one day die. But I do not believe that its hour of death has already struck or is near. The Jewish people is still full of vitality and love of life. One could perhaps slay it man by man, but it is far from ripe for a natural death from senility and exhaustion, and no people commits voluntary suicide whose every little vein swells with a hot desire for life.

And one more thing: have those who preach assimilation also considered what they are actually recommending? They always have only the most advanced countries of the West in mind. There, the Jew compromises nothing by assimilating. He may well renounce the inheritance of an immeasurable folk-past and a glorious history, but he at least gains education and refinement, he at least becomes a member of a culturally advanced people. But what fraction of the Jewish people lives in the civilized countries of the West? Scarcely an eighth. Seven-eighths of the Jewish people, on the other hand, live

16*