Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
236printed page
scan 250 of 434

236

...are different in belief, descent, customs, traditions, and appearance. These Jews alone should leave the lands that for them are a birthplace but not a homeland, almost a prison or a penal colony, and they should not, as now, wander aimlessly about the world like a frightened herd, but rather find in the ancient land of their fathers a publicly and legally secured homestead, where they will know no more persecution, where they may develop freely, where they can show themselves and the world what level of morality and education, what prosperity, indeed what physical regeneration they are able to achieve, when no pressure holds them down and no hatred, no contempt intimidates and embitters them.

You also know the objections to Zionism. They are always the same. Whatever critical remarks incomprehension, faintheartedness, Jewish anti-Semitism and misoneism or hatred of new ideas were able to devise, all of it was presented with triumphant expressions right at the earliest appearance of Zionism, and for ages the most venomous enmity has found no new argument against us. From all regions of thought, reasons have been brought against us. First, there is the ethnographic objection: the Jews are not a people. I admit that for many Jews of the West, the Jewish national consciousness has completely died out. But these Jews constitute barely a tenth of the Jewish whole, and the remaining nine-tenths are so clearly and surely conscious of their Jewish nationality that they would burst into laughter if one were to seriously assure them that there is no Jewish people. This feeling, this immediate, living conviction of the Eastern Jews that they are a people, relieves me of the necessity of any further proof. Then the political...