Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
11printed page
scan 25 of 434

11

reception will be prepared for his sermon. A small minority, which suffers precisely because a large majority will not recognize them as brothers, cannot possibly call out to this majority: "Let us be friends, Cinna!" This gesture is noble and magnanimous when the stronger one carries it out. If the weak, the persecuted, speaks of brotherhood to the enemy, then this posture has another name. Such a mission is at once unworthy and impracticable, and to demand that the Jews, for its sake, should renounce reclaiming the land of their fathers is tantamount to mocking them.

But what is all this talk of a mission of the Jewish people anyway? The nebulous phrase of the 'mission of peoples' is the mystical form in which the insight or intuition, gained through retrospective consideration of history, is expressed, that a given people has influenced the course of development of human civilization in a given way. This manner of expression confuses causality and finality. It presupposes that a people is assigned specific tasks from the outset and that it lives and acts with a view to solving these tasks. The truth is that it creates certain cultural-historical phenomena by living and acting as it can and must, by virtue of its natural disposition and the influence of all external conditions. A people has no other mission than to live and to fully develop all the abilities germinating within it. Without intention or consciousness, it then fulfills historical tasks for humanity all by itself. A downtrodden, persecuted, despised Jewry in the midst of antisemitic peoples is of no value to humanity; a free, strong, joyful Jewry will become a useful collaborator in the work of prog-