Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
220printed page
scan 234 of 434

220 has no value because it is not cultivated, be handed over under similar conditions as state lands are given to colonists in America: for an annual fee, which at the same time gradually pays off the naturally corresponding moderate purchase price. And we want the hundreds of thousands, hopefully even millions of Jews, who will take possession of the available parts of the country and revive the now-dead soil with the sweat of their brow and with loving labor—we want these Jews not to be subject to the arbitrariness of Turkish authorities, that the independence of their internal administration be granted to them by the Sublime Porte and guaranteed by the Great Powers, and until we have obtained these concessions from Turkey, this guarantee from the Powers, we not only do not favor the infiltration of small groups of Jewish Zionists into Palestine, but we expressly warn against it and implore the practical Zionists to settle not foreign, but only Palestinian Jews in their colonies.

Here, a first objection from the sober-minded practitioners is obvious, like the preliminary question that one poses to Zionism right at the threshold: “Why should Turkey give the Jews land and self-government? You yourself just said that Turkey has forbidden settlement by Jews in Palestine, indeed even entry into the country? And what interest do the Great Powers have in guaranteeing the self-government treaty that you wish to conclude with Turkey?”

To this I wish to answer briefly, yet hopefully sufficiently. Turkey has a financial interest in the immigration of the Jews, for which it shows the greatest understanding. The Holy Land is today four-fifths desolate and has only 600,000 inhabitants, of whom a good number