Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
212printed page
scan 226 of 434

212

"The Jews do not want to return to Palestine at all!" These 204 Jews in Basel assured that behind them stand several hundred thousand Jews who are ready today, at the first sign, to gird their loins and wander to Zion.

"The Jews have become a nation of shopkeepers and will never learn to guide the plow again!" All Jews who were settled in the agricultural colonies of Palestine have, under the most unfavorable conditions, proven themselves to be incomparably tenacious, diligent, and skilled tillers of the soil.

"Palestine cannot possibly accommodate the Jews!" Palestine – with the adjacent provinces – offers ample space for 12 to 15 million inhabitants, who, in addition to agriculture, also want to practice trades and serve a developing transit traffic and world trade.

"Palestine is not uninhabited, and the population will not want to be displaced!" We do not want to displace anyone, and we already have proof that the six hundred thousand Arabs who currently reside in the Holy Land will maintain good neighborly relations with the incoming Jews.

"The language question will form an insurmountable obstacle!" For people who come to London equipped with nothing but their jargon and speak passable English in three months and like natives in two years, who land in Argentina and after half a year chat fluently in Spanish with the gauchos, a language difficulty simply does not exist.

"The Powers will never consent to Palestine becoming Jewish!" Which Powers? Turkey? It is prepared to take in the Jews if it is offered advantages in return. The other Powers? Those who are tormented by the Jewish question welcome any solution to the difficulty, and the Zionist one most of all, because it is the most thorough. "The