Max Nordau · Zionist Writings · 1909
201printed page
scan 215 of 434

201

"Jews who possess only these intellectual abilities and not also corresponding character traits turn their backs on their people; only those remain who are either too dull to perceive the persecution and abuse painfully, or who are firm in character to the point of obstinacy and meet the more violent enmity with stronger defiance. If this double selection process continues for another generation or two, then the remaining Jewry will likely be a collection of intellectually insignificant, perhaps even limited, but unyieldingly stubborn people, impervious to any external influence, and whether such beings still possess the measure of adaptability that is indispensable for self-preservation amidst numerous and stronger opponents—that seems questionable to me.”

In October 1896, when I wrote this, I was not yet a Zionist. I knew nothing of the cause and did not even know the word. I was very positive in my prognosis, yet very uncertain in the therapy. Today, I am also no longer in doubt about the treatment. The falling away of educated Western Jewry cannot be prevented if it continues to be exposed to the attacks of antisemitism, which, I repeat, is not a passing phenomenon. Whoever wants to preserve the educated Jews for Judaism must open up the possibility for them to develop freely as Jews, to live their lives to the fullest, to feel themselves surrounded and supported by general respect and love, to satisfy every legitimate ambition, and these conditions can only be granted to them by their own Jewish commonwealth.

I have now had only the case of the educated Jews of the West, your case, in mind. I say it to you plainly to your face: Your old Jewish defiance is decayed and will not withstand the never-ceasing antisemitism for much longer.